Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,312
- Likes
- 31,158
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Moore. I genuinely had a dream last night that he single handedly won turned the game for the Hawks in the third quarter with two goals (one from outside 50) and 9 disposals. And I'm not even trading him in hahaha.
** PS don't judge, its been a long week
** PS don't judge, its been a long week
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Joined
- 26 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 3,147
- Likes
- 3,311
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Duncan vs Oliver vs Jelly
Duncan cheapest.
He's a very consistent player and really sturdy. And is in his prime at 27. Thoughts?
Oliver may have turned the corner with his massive game and may go on a run. Pretty consistent nonetheless.
Jelly is super premium. But can be a little fragile. Also doesn't have a good bye round right?
Duncan cheapest.
He's a very consistent player and really sturdy. And is in his prime at 27. Thoughts?
Oliver may have turned the corner with his massive game and may go on a run. Pretty consistent nonetheless.
Jelly is super premium. But can be a little fragile. Also doesn't have a good bye round right?
- Joined
- 21 Mar 2019
- Messages
- 2,295
- Likes
- 6,291
Round 14 should be ok unless you're loaded up with Giants and Crows, most of the other premos should be back by round 14.
If you've got a bunch of Richmond rookies then that's even better, as you'll likely be able to go two or maybe even 3 up once you shift them out (if you haven't already done so before round 14).
If you've got a bunch of Richmond rookies then that's even better, as you'll likely be able to go two or maybe even 3 up once you shift them out (if you haven't already done so before round 14).
Last edited:
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Dunkley
Never looked at Duncan, better than I thought. History suggests 107-110 player, doesn't have the high ceiling of others.
Kelly higher average and risk of missing games. Paired with Hately probably ok.
Olivier - similar scores to Duncan yet can punch a couple more big scores out.
Kelly for me. Whilst Olivier looks better, Geelong's run home is better and would put Duncan ahead of Clay.
Merrett vs Rocky for M8 - can get Rocky now, Merrett down the line (JKelly in this week is 1st trade). Going for league. If no Rocky, roll money towards Whitfield/Lloyd etc in two weeks.
Never looked at Duncan, better than I thought. History suggests 107-110 player, doesn't have the high ceiling of others.
Kelly higher average and risk of missing games. Paired with Hately probably ok.
Olivier - similar scores to Duncan yet can punch a couple more big scores out.
Kelly for me. Whilst Olivier looks better, Geelong's run home is better and would put Duncan ahead of Clay.
Merrett vs Rocky for M8 - can get Rocky now, Merrett down the line (JKelly in this week is 1st trade). Going for league. If no Rocky, roll money towards Whitfield/Lloyd etc in two weeks.
I’d take Jelly only if you’ve already got Fyfe, Neale, Macrae, Cripps (who I would have ahead of Jelly). If you’ve already burnt a few trades on corrections, I’d take Oliver.
I have JKelly but took him before the late out raising an additional adductor concern. I probably wouldn’t have taken him despite the good run if I had known he was still having adductor issues. If you take JKelly, be fully prepared to use another LTI trade or cop some missed games. Pairing with Hately isn’t a bad idea as I guess if JKelly is out, you should have Hately IN. I wouldn’t get Hately this round if not named though.
I did take Hately as well when JKelly was a late out but I probably didn’t think it through that much (cant do much an hour before Friday lockout!). I had thought JKelly was out for a few (as adductor sounded bad) so Hately would come off the bubble anyway but that was incorrect (not the worst to be wrong there as JKelly came back and posted a 150...!)
I have JKelly but took him before the late out raising an additional adductor concern. I probably wouldn’t have taken him despite the good run if I had known he was still having adductor issues. If you take JKelly, be fully prepared to use another LTI trade or cop some missed games. Pairing with Hately isn’t a bad idea as I guess if JKelly is out, you should have Hately IN. I wouldn’t get Hately this round if not named though.
I did take Hately as well when JKelly was a late out but I probably didn’t think it through that much (cant do much an hour before Friday lockout!). I had thought JKelly was out for a few (as adductor sounded bad) so Hately would come off the bubble anyway but that was incorrect (not the worst to be wrong there as JKelly came back and posted a 150...!)
- Joined
- 26 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 3,147
- Likes
- 3,311
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Thanks. Swaying towards Kelly again because I don't see him sliding to m7-m8 scores. Oliver could and so could Duncan. Currently have cripps macrae fyfe already so adding another ultra premium seems good.
I would go merrett way before rock. I went rock because he was cheap.. But merrett for consistency and to be honest... His ceiling is similar
I would go merrett way before rock. I went rock because he was cheap.. But merrett for consistency and to be honest... His ceiling is similar