Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Drew]

Defence upgrade time!

Tom Stewart vs Sicily

 

[Juzzo]

Defence upgrade time!

Tom Stewart vs Sicily

tough one to split, maybe who suits byes better, probably Sicily?

 

[Drew]

tough one to split, maybe who suits byes better, probably Sicily?

Probably Sicily in regards to byes, but I’d still need at least another premo defence upgrade at some point to I could still aim to get him before then. Stewart's a little bit cheaper, so that could get me over the line.

 

[Bomber18]

Macrae v Neale?

Blakely flagged a possible tag for Neale this round.... can definitely see it happening if I bring him in and then not hapening if I don’t!

 

[inwhiterooms]

Macrae v Neale?

Blakely flagged a possible tag for Neale this round.... can definitely see it happening if I bring him in and then not hapening if I don’t!

I'd take Neale, despite the tag concerns this week. Can't go wrong with either though.

 

[inwhiterooms]

Hurn vs Macrae as trade in targets this week? Either of the two will be coming in for Walsh.

 

[Grundogging]

Macrae v Neale?

Blakely flagged a possible tag for Neale this round.... can definitely see it happening if I bring him in and then not hapening if I don’t!

I doubt Blakely had the run in his legs to go with Neale for 120 minutes.

Neale probably has enough midfield craft and support now to fight his way through a tag eventually as well, even if it does stick early.

He's already shown he can break through and impact a game in 10-15 minutes on a number of occasions which is all we need for supercoach scoring purposes.

 

[Ricky Bobby]

Hurn (14% owned) v Whitfield (31% owned) ?

 

[Darkie]

Hurn (14% owned) v Whitfield (31% owned) ?

If you’re only getting one, Whitfield. Exact same average despite an injury game, and cheaper. If you’re getting both, maybe Hurn first, due to his BE.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

Probably Sicily in regards to byes, but I’d still need at least another premo defence upgrade at some point to I could still aim to get him before then. Stewart's a little bit cheaper, so that could get me over the line.

If Sicily has to play full back on the big guns like he did this week I would steer clear. Needs Frawley or brand back so he can play 3rd man

 

[Drew]

If Sicily has to play full back on the big guns like he did this week I would steer clear. Needs Frawley or brand back so he can play 3rd man

Cheers mate.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Hurn vs Macrae as trade in targets this week? Either of the two will be coming in for Walsh.

This is currently my X v Y with both around the same price. I'm going Macrae.

 

[Bomber18]

I'd take Neale, despite the tag concerns this week. Can't go wrong with either though.

I doubt Blakely had the run in his legs to go with Neale for 120 minutes.

Neale probably has enough midfield craft and support now to fight his way through a tag eventually as well, even if it does stick early.

He's already shown he can break through and impact a game in 10-15 minutes on a number of occasions which is all we need for supercoach scoring purposes.

Thanks guys.

After looking at my bye rounds, it occurred to me that I don’t have any with the middle bye (R13?) but quite a few with Macrae’s bye (R12?) so Neale makes sense despite the extra cost.

 

[quite ironic]

Stewart vs Hurn vs Sicily (for Moore)

Taking into account bye structure that Stewart and Hurn would be crap and Sicily great but also the fact he is arguably the most over priced for current performance of the lot.

Already have Lloyd, Whitfield and Williams.

 

[Steuby]

Lloyd vs Zerrett

 

[quite ironic]

Lloyd vs Zerrett

Lloyd if you have only one of Whitfield, Hurn, Stewart.

Merrett if you have only 3 of Cripps, Neale, Fyfe, Oliver, Macrae.

 

[bloke]

Billings vs Walters?

 

[Maso]

Hurn / Llooooooyyyyyyyd / Whitfield this decision is giving me a headache

 

[Kingkongbunndys]

Hurn / Llooooooyyyyyyyd / Whitfield this decision is giving me a headache

Whitfield

 

[anfa18]

Stewart vs Rich