Opinion Rate My AFL SuperCoach Team

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
Pizza safety and Bomber18 can you give us ur opinion on the bombers midfielders from a non SuperCoach point of view? My take is that u need some better ball users to get more game time through there. Can you see parish and McGrath getting more minutes or do u think they will go with similar splits.
I would like to know where the better ball users are hiding so that we can put them on ball :ROFLMAO:

Re midfield splits, I think maybe other than Shiel and Zerrett, there could be a fair bit of rotation with the mids. Stringer/AMT I think will get rotations in the CBs during critical stages. Heppell and Zaha are quite underdone this preseason so could get used in other roles (although we’ll need more intraclub/preseason games to know for sure where they are at).

McGrath being talked up for mid time as he has been for most years. Hard to know but I am starting to wonder if the dons are better off developing him into that gun HB (which was where he was prolific as a junior). I think he may rotate with Heppell a bit between Def/Mid.

The coaches have honestly butchered Parish’s development. They have changed his role constantly: outside mid, inside mid, half forward. It will be interesting to see if he gets a settled role this season but I couldnt touch him in SC without a clear indication of role. He did quite well in an inside mid role last season but then we pushed him back to the HFF to let DClarke in the CBs as a tagger.

DSmith is the one most are interested in. I don’t really see his mid time suffering so much that he becomes a full time small fwd like he was at GWS. Let’s not forget that he broke the tackles record in 2018, he offers that manic pressure around stoppages more so than any other player. We also have AMT/Fantasia/Stringer types up forward when needed for forward pressure so I think DSmith will get sufficient mid time to be relevant. Not expecting 100 but 90-95 avg at 330k is more than enough.
 
Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,257
Likes
36,921
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Must admit I'm very cautious on Smith ...

- Are his pressure acts good enough ... I'd say he gets the tick
- Is his disposal good enough .... I'd say he gets the tick
- Does the coach like him ... I'd say he gets the tick ...

- Is he used enough in his optimal role ... nope for me ... and that will be my deciding factor ...
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
Must admit I'm very cautious on Smith ...

- Are his pressure acts good enough ... I'd say he gets the tick
- Is his disposal good enough .... I'd say he gets the tick
- Does the coach like him ... I'd say he gets the tick ...

- Is he used enough in his optimal role ... nope for me ... and that will be my deciding factor ...
What mid/fwd split would be enough to be an “optimal” role? 50-50 M/F not enough? From pizzasafety’s prospectus stats he had a 61 mid/39 fwd split during his 98 avg season. Averaged 90 at GWS with 65%+ fwd time.
 
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,763
Likes
11,759
AFL Club
West Coast
Must admit I'm very cautious on Smith ...

- Are his pressure acts good enough ... I'd say he gets the tick
- Is his disposal good enough .... I'd say he gets the tick
- Does the coach like him ... I'd say he gets the tick ...

- Is he used enough in his optimal role ... nope for me ... and that will be my deciding factor ...
You know in some ways I am beginning to think that D Smith is one of the most influential players in SC team structure. Hypothetical. If on the eve of the season P Cripps gets injured then most coaches could find a satisfactory replacement. Same for Lloyd in defence and othjer premium players etc etc

But if Polony Smith gets injured on the eve of Rd 1 there are a hell of a lot of coaches who having already used up most of their cash to maximise the return that are either going to a) seriously rearrange their team (yuk, just after you think you had it nailed, b) find a similar priced player they probably are not as confident with (just plain yuk) or c) drop to a rookie/rookish player (say Bonar anyone and is there such a word as rookish?). In some ways the structure of many teams pivot on him playing and being successful.

For the record I have D Smith and I am wondering that question myself
 
Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,257
Likes
36,921
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
What mid/fwd split would be enough to be an “optimal” role? 50-50 M/F not enough? From pizzasafety’s prospectus stats he had a 61 mid/39 fwd split during his 98 avg season. Averaged 90 at GWS with 65%+ fwd time.
60 / 40 would be enough for me to lock him in .... especially if attending stoppages ...

40 / 60 ... I'll be looking elsewhere ... so I guess 50/50 is the bare minimum ...
 
Joined
22 Feb 2013
Messages
9,668
Likes
20,502
AFL Club
Hawthorn
You know in some ways I am beginning to think that D Smith is one of the most influential players in SC team structure. Hypothetical. If on the eve of the season P Cripps gets injured then most coaches could find a satisfactory replacement. Same for Lloyd in defence and othjer premium players etc etc

But if Polony Smith gets injured on the eve of Rd 1 there are a hell of a lot of coaches who having already used up most of their cash to maximise the return that are either going to a) seriously rearrange their team (yuk, just after you think you had it nailed, b) find a similar priced player they probably are not as confident with (just plain yuk) or c) drop to a rookie/rookish player (say Bonar anyone and is there such a word as rookish?). In some ways the structure of many teams pivot on him playing and being successful.

For the record I have D Smith and I am wondering that question myself
Lynch is only 50k more :sneaky:
 
Joined
4 Jan 2016
Messages
822
Likes
878
AFL Club
Essendon
I don't think I'll roll with this structure, but I might. So I'd like to get some opinions on this strategy.

Curnow is in ATS as a POD and value pick, he averaged over 107 after round 10 when Teague took over and I can't see that changing.
Treloar and Daniel are my other POD's and Lynch is there cos I like his value, plus he's a Tiger.

3/5's of stuff all ITB too.

So let me know what ya'll think, am I missing something? Am I barking up the wrong tree? Or just stark, raving mad?
Structurally looks pretty good! Like the Treloar pick, have wondered a bit why he’s not as popular. Went 124 SC and 116 DT post byes last year, I picked him up for that period so have good memories of that! I’m looking at him a bit more closely too as a starter as well.

Daniel is a good POD too I reckon, I think he doesn’t offer much value at his price but I think he’ll be pretty consistent again.

ECurnow is an interesting POD. Would a 107 avg as a $500k player be a win for you? It probably would be but if he goes closer to 100, he’d just be a bit of a list clogger. Not enough upside for me personally.
@OnTopBar don't do the Curnow move haha I did it 2 years ago after her had that blinder of a start and it just didn't go to fruition... I'm sure there's a way you can find some more coin to get him to a Cogs or something??? Maybe reduce one of your guys down back???
Anyway, just my 3c but that move (and probably some others) cost me big time that year...
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
@OnTopBar don't do the Curnow move haha I did it 2 years ago after her had that blinder of a start and it just didn't go to fruition... I'm sure there's a way you can find some more coin to get him to a Cogs or something??? Maybe reduce one of your guys down back???
Anyway, just my 3c but that move (and probably some others) cost me big time that year...
Cheers, I'll be watching him, it's actually a toss up for me between him and Lyons as M5.
 
Joined
4 Jan 2016
Messages
822
Likes
878
AFL Club
Essendon
He played 61% midfield and had that many tackles per game, I think that means it's only unsustainable if he doesn't get more mid time.

He's 4th in our mid rotations behind Shiel, Merrett and Heppel if fit. We missed his pressure at the contest immensely in the 2nd half of the year and if they have any idea what they're doing they'll use him a lot through the midfield.
No truer words spoken... Obviously Clarke will get a run in there from time to time, but even then, Dev's pressure is next level... We have no real players with "balls and grit" so he's a MUST in the middle for me for at least the same, if not more time...
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
It would be remiss of me not to post something out of the ordinary so here goes :-

LAIRD , SICILY , HOUSTON * , DAWSON * , DOCHERTY , Hill * / McLennan , Gould

CRIPPS , OLIVER , Sier , Rowell , Anderson , Bonar * , Ash * , Caldwell / Pickett , Mahony * , Rivers *

GRUNDY , GAWN / Comben *

WHITFIELD * , MARTIN * , HEENEY * , TJ LYNCH , D SMITH * , Cockatoo * / Brander * , Cameron *

$ 8,800.00 in the Bank

14 possible keepers from the start

+ Bonar , Cockatoo , Hill , Sier

Cons

* locked in 5/6 forwards from the start
* locked in 4/5 backs from the start
* can M3-M8 all average enough to get to say $ 400k each
* can the bench all generate enough $$$ for upgrades

just imagine though if it did work ?
 
Joined
4 Mar 2014
Messages
1,802
Likes
586
AFL Club
Hawthorn
2020 SuperCoach V3.0

D: Stewart*, Docherty, Doedee, S.Hill D/F, H.Young, Starcevich D/M (Kennerley, Gould)

M: McRae, Cripps, Dunkley, Dangerfield, Lyons, Rowell, Caldwell, Pickett (McHenry, Collier-Dawson, Mead)

R: Grundy, Gawn (Comben R/F)

F: Whitfield M/F, Martin M/F, Heeney M/F, D.Smith M/F, King, Rankine (Cavarra, D.Cameron R/F)

* Stewart could become Laird if he doesn’t recover and show enough form in the preseason games
 
Joined
13 Mar 2016
Messages
1,810
Likes
5,993
AFL Club
West Coast
ok, long time listener, first time caller here...

$18.1k in the bank, 8-13-9 bye spread at present and hopefully 14 keepers if TJL & Devon do their thing. I think all but Gawn, Grundy & Whitfield have potential upside to their scoring...

Hoping Darcy Cameron winds up taking Cox's forward spot.. would be handy to have a playing R/F rookie to switch with Comben...

1580945347726.png
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
ok, long time listener, first time caller here...

$18.1k in the bank, 8-13-9 bye spread at present and hopefully 14 keepers if TJL & Devon do their thing. I think all but Gawn, Grundy & Whitfield have potential upside to their scoring...

Hoping Darcy Cameron winds up taking Cox's forward spot.. would be handy to have a playing R/F rookie to switch with Comben...

View attachment 15383
isn't the whole idea of Comben is that he can VC/C loop with Grundy & Gawn for 18 of the 21 rounds ? so pretty much permanent captain if Gawn is OK to start.

Hoping myself that Cameron is named and viable , so he and King can provide cover for the Cocky & Rankine if necessary.


Certainly a strong enough side on paper , will all depend on the rookies being named.

Not much $$$ to move though if the $ 117,300.00 players are missing Round 1.
 
Joined
13 Mar 2016
Messages
1,810
Likes
5,993
AFL Club
West Coast
isn't the whole idea of Comben is that he can VC/C loop with Grundy & Gawn for 18 of the 21 rounds ? so pretty much permanent captain if Gawn is OK to start.

Hoping myself that Cameron is named and viable , so he and King can provide cover for the Cocky & Rankine if necessary.


Certainly a strong enough side on paper , will all depend on the rookies being named.

Not much $$$ to move though if the $ 117,300.00 players are missing Round 1.
Yes I should've swapped Cameron & Comben around before posting, Comben would be the VC/C loophole
 
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
510
Likes
1,721
AFL Club
Richmond
ok, long time listener, first time caller here...

$18.1k in the bank, 8-13-9 bye spread at present and hopefully 14 keepers if TJL & Devon do their thing. I think all but Gawn, Grundy & Whitfield have potential upside to their scoring...

Hoping Darcy Cameron winds up taking Cox's forward spot.. would be handy to have a playing R/F rookie to switch with Comben...

View attachment 15383
Nice looking team. If Cameron doesn't get a gig and there are no other rookie priced rucks playing will u just have Comben there and hope for the best with Gawn?
At the moment that's my main deterrent to starting Gawn. What do you do if he pulls up sore after round 1 and misses a game? Do you trade him out, or trade in a Ceglar/Ryder forward, or take the donut?
 
Joined
13 Mar 2016
Messages
1,810
Likes
5,993
AFL Club
West Coast
Nice looking team. If Cameron doesn't get a gig and there are no other rookie priced rucks playing will u just have Comben there and hope for the best with Gawn?
At the moment that's my main deterrent to starting Gawn. What do you do if he pulls up sore after round 1 and misses a game? Do you trade him out, or trade in a Ceglar/Ryder forward, or take the donut?
Well that's the risk isn't it.. last year I had Lobb in the forward line as cover given he was both underpriced and would score reasonably... wish I hadn't in the end given Gawn & Grundy went from strength to strength.. I'm not sure tbh if Gawn is not looking 100% - will need to investigate!
 
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
510
Likes
1,721
AFL Club
Richmond
Well that's the risk isn't it.. last year I had Lobb in the forward line as cover given he was both underpriced and would score reasonably... wish I hadn't in the end given Gawn & Grundy went from strength to strength.. I'm not sure tbh if Gawn is not looking 100% - will need to investigate!
Yeah it's a tough one. After the last couple years we sort of expect 22 games at 125+ from them now. Maybe they will keep that going, but the knee injury is enough to put me off Gawn without backup.
 
Top