Opinion Rate My AFL SuperCoach Team
- Thread starter Ironhawk
- Start date
- Joined
- 11 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 5,329
- Likes
- 28,688
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Hi Bomber ,
I have a herald sun subscription and can't/couldn't get live scores again over the weekend.
They are stopping all the other sites that do live scores through court action or trying to , if i hear anything i will certainly keep u informed and vice versa.
If you noticed Fan Footy only updated at the end of each quarter , not through the quarter unfortunately.
Supercoach only give you live scores of players in your team , not the teams itself.
Hope that helped.
FT
I have a herald sun subscription and can't/couldn't get live scores again over the weekend.
They are stopping all the other sites that do live scores through court action or trying to , if i hear anything i will certainly keep u informed and vice versa.
If you noticed Fan Footy only updated at the end of each quarter , not through the quarter unfortunately.
Supercoach only give you live scores of players in your team , not the teams itself.
Hope that helped.
FT
Last edited:
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Cheers Bomber, appreciate your praise.
Yeah have to admit this is the first time I've had Steven in my team since early January, didn't expect him to play like he did and given his cheaper price, good bye and the uncertainties around the other midpriced players I feel like he is now worth picking. You were definitely ahead of everybody else in thinking he was a good pick.
I'm also thinking of bringing in Noble for McAsey because given I'm paying so much for the player I feel like I might pick a player slightly more expensive who is more of a genuine cash cow. To do this I've downgraded Macrae to Dunkley, most likely to your dismay
. I can then put him on field over Brander and have moved Brander forward, moved Budarick to midfield and moved Bailey Williams into the D bench. I have got rid of Sharp but hope either he or Budarick play in round 1. I think if Devon Robertson doesn't play I might just pick Mitchell Hibberd in his place and hope he eventually gets games. If two players miss it might cause even more headaches and I’ll try to pick a more expensive rookie who I hope might play as not doing this might run the risk of donuts. Doing Houston to Cumming to facilitate that or even moving down to a Yeo/Zerrett/Cogs at M5 whilst keeping Oliver at M4 are other options.
I’m also annoyed I can’t start Cumming as I think he’d be a more genuinely decent D5 who would make cash but the only way I can currently facilitate it is to trade Macrae to Yeo instead of Dunkley, which I’m not sure about.
Yeah have to admit this is the first time I've had Steven in my team since early January, didn't expect him to play like he did and given his cheaper price, good bye and the uncertainties around the other midpriced players I feel like he is now worth picking. You were definitely ahead of everybody else in thinking he was a good pick.
I'm also thinking of bringing in Noble for McAsey because given I'm paying so much for the player I feel like I might pick a player slightly more expensive who is more of a genuine cash cow. To do this I've downgraded Macrae to Dunkley, most likely to your dismay
. I can then put him on field over Brander and have moved Brander forward, moved Budarick to midfield and moved Bailey Williams into the D bench. I have got rid of Sharp but hope either he or Budarick play in round 1. I think if Devon Robertson doesn't play I might just pick Mitchell Hibberd in his place and hope he eventually gets games. If two players miss it might cause even more headaches and I’ll try to pick a more expensive rookie who I hope might play as not doing this might run the risk of donuts. Doing Houston to Cumming to facilitate that or even moving down to a Yeo/Zerrett/Cogs at M5 whilst keeping Oliver at M4 are other options.I’m also annoyed I can’t start Cumming as I think he’d be a more genuinely decent D5 who would make cash but the only way I can currently facilitate it is to trade Macrae to Yeo instead of Dunkley, which I’m not sure about.
Cheers Bomber, appreciate your praise.
Yeah have to admit this is the first time I've had Steven in my team since early January, didn't expect him to play like he did and given his cheaper price, good bye and the uncertainties around the other midpriced players I feel like he is now worth picking. You were definitely ahead of everybody else in thinking he was a good pick.
I'm also thinking of bringing in Noble for McAsey because given I'm paying so much for the player I feel like I might pick a player slightly more expensive who is more of a genuine cash cow. To do this I've downgraded Macrae to Dunkley, most likely to your dismay. I can then put him on field over Brander and have moved Brander forward, moved Budarick to midfield and moved Bailey Williams into the D bench. I have got rid of Sharp but hope either he or Budarick play in round 1. I think if Devon Robertson doesn't play I might just pick Mitchell Hibberd in his place and hope he eventually gets games. If two players miss it might cause even more headaches and I’ll try to pick a more expensive rookie who I hope might play as not doing this might run the risk of donuts. Doing Houston to Cumming to facilitate that or even moving down to a Yeo/Zerrett/Cogs at M5 whilst keeping Oliver at M4 are other options.
I’m also annoyed I can’t start Cumming as I think he’d be a more genuinely decent D5 who would make cash but the only way I can currently facilitate it is to trade Macrae to Yeo instead of Dunkley, which I’m not sure about.
Yeah have to admit this is the first time I've had Steven in my team since early January, didn't expect him to play like he did and given his cheaper price, good bye and the uncertainties around the other midpriced players I feel like he is now worth picking. You were definitely ahead of everybody else in thinking he was a good pick.
I'm also thinking of bringing in Noble for McAsey because given I'm paying so much for the player I feel like I might pick a player slightly more expensive who is more of a genuine cash cow. To do this I've downgraded Macrae to Dunkley, most likely to your dismay
. I can then put him on field over Brander and have moved Brander forward, moved Budarick to midfield and moved Bailey Williams into the D bench. I have got rid of Sharp but hope either he or Budarick play in round 1. I think if Devon Robertson doesn't play I might just pick Mitchell Hibberd in his place and hope he eventually gets games. If two players miss it might cause even more headaches and I’ll try to pick a more expensive rookie who I hope might play as not doing this might run the risk of donuts. Doing Houston to Cumming to facilitate that or even moving down to a Yeo/Zerrett/Cogs at M5 whilst keeping Oliver at M4 are other options.I’m also annoyed I can’t start Cumming as I think he’d be a more genuinely decent D5 who would make cash but the only way I can currently facilitate it is to trade Macrae to Yeo instead of Dunkley, which I’m not sure about.
Maybe I'm wrong on Dunkley, I have seen some good coaches taking him. I generally avoid his type though so I will stay strong. It's mainly the Neale v Oliver XY that I'm struggling with. Desparetely wanted Neale for more certainty but Oliver provides very useful cash for rookies.
Interesting to hear that you are so keen on Cummings though. I think he's a massive red herring with ZWilliams to come in. If he was cheaper, I wouldn't mind taking the punt but at 245k, he really needs better JS in my view.
- Joined
- 24 Feb 2015
- Messages
- 6,697
- Likes
- 30,160
- AFL Club
- Sydney
You've just reminded me of the tweet you linked last night with that spreadsheet of CBAs and Wing attendances I glanced at before going to sleep. It was Oliver and his CBAs between the first Marsh series without Brayshaw and the second Marsh gave with Brayshaw. I took Oliver out but need to have a closer look at this.
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon
The Laird vs Houston debate is interesting, I definitely prefer Laird over both Sicily and Houston but replacing him with one of these other players has always seemed like the easiest way to save money with my team. I only hope Houston has a few detractors before round one. Starcevich will probably be named for round 1 in my opinion, I think he's done enough in preseason to show he's ahead of some of the lesser types in Brisbane's first team. I would also think Robertson is an ok chance to debut given he attended a whopping 13 centre bounces on the weekend.
I'm not as Keane on Neale as some others have been given he averaged 115 from rounds 5-23 which included the 190 game against Richmond. I think when he started receiving a lot of attention from opposition taggers his scores sometimes took a hit. Definitely expect him to be a top 6 player but I think there is better value elsewhere. Could be in for a severe early burn if I don't start him though as he can go ballistic in games where he isn't tagged. I don't feel the same way about Dunkley as I did a few weeks ago but he was still the midfielder I wanted to pick outside of the 5 guys I was picking so if I needed to save money he was always a fair chance to come in to replace Macrae. Just need a bit of luck regarding role and who Libba affects when he comes back in, as we saw in the 1st half of last year, he also had a big impact on Macrae.
Definitely a concern with Williams coming back for Cumming, but he put up that score on the weekend with Whitfield in the team playing Williams role. He put up a 90 and a 69 in his last 2 games playing half-back last year with the game in the middle being the one where he tagged Brodie Smith. I think those two scores combined with his two preseason scores and his NEAFL form suggest to me that he can average 75 as a defender, but there's always a risk involved in more expensive players. But I agree it's not worth dropping Dunkley to Yeo just to get him and Noble has decent scoring potential if he can fix his kicking and improve his SC : DT ratio.
I'm not as Keane on Neale as some others have been given he averaged 115 from rounds 5-23 which included the 190 game against Richmond. I think when he started receiving a lot of attention from opposition taggers his scores sometimes took a hit. Definitely expect him to be a top 6 player but I think there is better value elsewhere. Could be in for a severe early burn if I don't start him though as he can go ballistic in games where he isn't tagged. I don't feel the same way about Dunkley as I did a few weeks ago but he was still the midfielder I wanted to pick outside of the 5 guys I was picking so if I needed to save money he was always a fair chance to come in to replace Macrae. Just need a bit of luck regarding role and who Libba affects when he comes back in, as we saw in the 1st half of last year, he also had a big impact on Macrae.
Definitely a concern with Williams coming back for Cumming, but he put up that score on the weekend with Whitfield in the team playing Williams role. He put up a 90 and a 69 in his last 2 games playing half-back last year with the game in the middle being the one where he tagged Brodie Smith. I think those two scores combined with his two preseason scores and his NEAFL form suggest to me that he can average 75 as a defender, but there's always a risk involved in more expensive players. But I agree it's not worth dropping Dunkley to Yeo just to get him and Noble has decent scoring potential if he can fix his kicking and improve his SC : DT ratio.
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Joined
- 13 Dec 2018
- Messages
- 785
- Likes
- 1,660
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon