Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[nath_99]

Ryan v Whitfield

 

[Deeman1]

Ryan v Whitfield

I think is a true 50/50 call and probably comes down to personal preference.

Both have injury problems, Whitfield has 4 years over 97 v Ryan 1 year over 97.

Whitfield I think will be the more 'popluar', but it is probably a toss of a coin.

 

[nicohighscore]

Ryan v Whitfield

Ryan seems to be posting more lower scores ( sub 80) - and it would feel Whitfield ceiling is higher.

 

[nath_99]

Ryan seems to be posting more lower scores ( sub 80) - and it would feel Whitfield ceiling is higher.

View attachment 25413

Wow! Thanks very much mate!

 

[Shaunpro1]

Ryan v Whitfield

Havent looked into it but surely Ryan scores worse with Pearce and Hamling in the side taking defensive marks? Big ask to go at 107 again.

 

[Leroy]

Got a team but it doesn't look right yet. I've got a lot of spend on higher priced rookies eating up the dollars but that's not bad as a starting place necessarily.

It's left me with something like this however:
Harmes, B Brown/Daniher, Ziebell
vs
Rookie D4, Dunkley, Rookie F4

3 cheap rookies forward and back seems light, but 3 mid-pricers seems like it is asking for trouble.

 

[Brettthejett]

3 cheap rookies forward and back seems light, but 3 mid-pricers seems like it is asking for trouble.

Yes your right it’s a fine balancing act myself at the moment I’m looking at the likes of Hatley/Caldwell types that he’s have let go due to depth in there midfield and lower price premos like Heeney/Newman that should hopefully return a decent return for there investment.

ATM u have a
3-1-4 Lloyd,Stewart,Williams,Newman
3-4-4 Neale,Oliver,Macrea,Green,Caldwell,Hately, Heppell
0-2-1 Pruess,Martin
3-1-4 Danger,Marshall,Walters,Heeney

Split

 

[Zim^zuM]

Preus/dunkley (or similar to Dunkley) (F3)

vs

gawn/daniher (F3)

 

[Snowman]

Preus/dunkley (or similar to Dunkley) (F3)

vs

gawn/daniher (F3)

Its to hard to give an honest opinion without really knowing the rest of your set up. But you'd be a braver man than me to start with Daniher at F3

 

[TopBillings]

Docherty & Rowell
V
Stewart & Taranto

 

[Juzzo]

Bolton v Butters (I think at least one of these will be in my team)

 

[BIGB0Y]

Bolton v Butters (I think at least one of these will be in my team)

Butler has been in and out of my team. Port has the best run in the comp so butler for me.

 

[BIGB0Y]

Preus/dunkley (or similar to Dunkley) (F3)

vs

gawn/daniher (F3)

Gawn

 

[Juzzo]

Butler has been in and out of my team. Port has the best run in the comp so butler for me.

Butters? yeah?

 

[BIGB0Y]

Sorry mate butters

 

[BIGB0Y]

Sidebottom/ziebell v de goey/rozee? Stuck on this one

 

[Darkie]

Ryan seems to be posting more lower scores ( sub 80) - and it would feel Whitfield ceiling is higher.

View attachment 25413

I was about to ask what snazzy new website you are using 🙂

 

[OnTopBar]

Bolton v Butters (I think at least one of these will be in my team)

I currently have Bolton and expect him to ave. around 95. My worry with him is that he hasn't been renowned for having a large tank and a low PC% so maybe the longer quarters and less rotations might have a bearing on his impact. That being said, he has the ability to hit the scoreboard.

 

[scarfaceclaw]

Caleb Daniel v Tom Stewart? (i have Daniel atm)

 

[Jurn Stern]

Sidebottom/ziebell v de goey/rozee? Stuck on this one

It’s hard to know how De Goey goes with extra mid time, but he’s never played a full season so I’m cautious on a guy like that. I like the other 3, but I’d almost go Rozee, Ziebell and cash.