Discussion General Discussion

Which team wins a final first?

  • Essendon

    Votes: 23 28.4%
  • Tasmania

    Votes: 58 71.6%

  • Total voters
    81
Joined
27 Feb 2021
Messages
171
Likes
1,009
AFL Club
Carlton
Not quite official confirmation on how SC will handle it, but close enough to...

Nothing much really changes for us SC players.

We were always trying to pick players who are part of their teams selected 22 - and we still are. If one of your players is not selected in the 22, then you consider them dropped/injured and don't consider them for an onfield spot - regardless of being made the 23rd player or not. If you have other emergencies you use them. If you have no other emergencies and you use a sub - then you take whatever you might get (if anything).

We are all in the same boat if we use a sub as a strategic donut - lap of the gods stuff that should be avoided at all costs.

If cash generation is affected via poor sub scores, you just have to accept that you picked a poor rookie.
 
Joined
13 Mar 2016
Messages
1,810
Likes
5,993
AFL Club
West Coast
Nothing much really changes for us SC players.

We were always trying to pick players who are part of their teams selected 22 - and we still are. If one of your players is not selected in the 22, then you consider them dropped/injured and don't consider them for an onfield spot - regardless of being made the 23rd player or not. If you have other emergencies you use them. If you have no other emergencies and you use a sub - then you take whatever you might get (if anything).

We are all in the same boat if we use a sub as a strategic donut - lap of the gods stuff that should be avoided at all costs.

If cash generation is affected via poor sub scores, you just have to accept that you picked a poor rookie.
Yeah you’d mostly just be pissed if your floating donut captain suddenly comes on as a sub which is a slightly higher chance now with this new rule - especially if you only find out which emergency player is going to be the sub an hour before the game!
 
Joined
10 Feb 2014
Messages
11,375
Likes
21,228
AFL Club
Essendon
On a non SC level, just seems to stuff with fringe players who (depending on schedule) will either play part of a seniors game or miss a full game of Seniors and Reserves.

It just seems poorly thought out in general. But are we surprised? Footy's always had bad luck involved with injury - if the player can't play he can't play and you're one short. **** happens. This is a ramshackle attempt to seem to be doing something, to protect the AFL's "interests". IMHO.
 
Last edited:
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,769
Likes
26,254
AFL Club
Sydney
I'm 43 and know how you feel. Waking up in the middle of the night and not being able to get back to sleep tossing over players, structures in your head seriously stressing me out lol
I assume I'll have the only "dream" I ever remember each year tonight that for some reason I miss round 1 and my whole season is over :LOL:
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,401
Likes
65,467
AFL Club
Collingwood
Looks like Gill had to cancel his haircut to spend those extra minutes cooking up the injury sub rules.
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,769
Likes
26,254
AFL Club
Sydney
Good old KB... the guy that people over 45 remember as a great player and everyone under 40 only know as the total ****wit who started the whole lets change the rules for the sake of it movement :(

On a positive for KB he's got Hocking and Gil now to erase him from the record books as the worst thing to hit the game though his holding the ball legacy is still the absolute worst part of the game!
 
Joined
16 May 2019
Messages
1,021
Likes
3,954
AFL Club
Sydney
https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/k...r/news-story/7f21fa002d912ab9ac08361652a57697
Meet the super nan who is one of Australia’s best KFC SuperCoaches.

Elizabeth Mullin, a 73-year-old from Lower Templestowe, was the top-ranked female in KFC SuperCoach last season — finishing 75th overall.
She had played for three seasons but never taken Australia’s favourite fantasy game seriously until last year.
“I think SuperCoach is just 80 per cent luck, 20 per cent knowledge. You have to be really lucky,” she said.
That undersells her achievement though.
Mullin earned bragging rights at home by finishing about 900 places ahead of her grandson and avid KFC SuperCoach Zak Yahiat.
“When I got to close to 100, Zak and all of his mates were discussing what I should be doing,” she said.
“I would still do what I want to do, but they would all be saying ‘tell your nana this’. I loved it.
“Apart from anything because he lives with us, it’s a really good way to bond with someone who’s younger than you.
“He’s 21. I’m 73. We can discuss this with one another and debate with one another.”
The only disappointment from her season was losing a head-to-head battle with husband Don, something she’s often reminded of.
KFC SuperCoach also helps them keep in touch with their son Stewart, who lives in Denmark and is part of their league every year.
“The four of us play and we’re all a bit competitive,” Mullin said.
“My husband keeps saying to people, ‘when it was head-to-head I beat her’.”

Elizabeth Mullin has bragging rights at home over her grandson Zak. Picture: Jason Edwards.Source:News Corp Australia
And she’s picked up some of the KFC SuperCoach lingo from her grandson too.
Elizabeth loves talking PODs (point-of-difference selections), premiums and rookies and has put in hours of study to prepare her team for another successful season.
“There were two people I started with last year which he called PODs — one was Petracca and one was Brayshaw from Fremantle,” she said.
“I thought those two were due for a good year.
“I said to Zak, ‘I’m going to have them’ and he said ‘you have to have Dustin Martin’.
“And I said ‘I’m not having Dustin Martin’. He plays really well in the finals, but during the year if he’s in the mood he plays and if he’s not, he doesn’t.”
Her gut feel paid off.
Petracca averaged 117.5 points a game, Brayshaw 101.3 and Martin 100.8.

Sam Docherty is a player Elizabeth Mullins picks every year.Source:Getty Images
A diehard Carlton supporter, Mullin said Sam Docherty and Clayton Oliver were her must-have players every year.
She’s particularly keen on North Melbourne’s Jy Simpkin this season but can’t fit him in to her starting team, which includes St Kilda co-captain Jack Steele after he was crucial to her top-100 campaign.
“Last year I was watching a St Kilda game and I said to Zak, ‘there’s a young midfielder I want to get in, but I don’t know what his name is’,” she said.
“He showed me a photo and it was Jack Steele. I said ‘as soon as I can afford him I’m going to get him in’.

St Kilda co-captain Jack Steele helped launch Elizabeth into the top-100 last season.Source:News Corp Australia
“He said ‘no, you don’t want to get him’. We had this debate. But I ended up getting him in and he was such good value for me.”
Elizabeth hopes her success inspires more women and grandparents to get involved in KFC SuperCoach this year.

Elizabeth is a big fan of Jy Simpkin but can’t fit him into her budget.Source:News Corp Australia
ELIZABETH MULLIN’S FIVE STANDOUT KFC SUPERCOACH PICKS
1. Rory Laird (Adelaide) DEF — “Rory Laird’s one I usually have on the backline.”
2. Sam Docherty (Carlton) DEF — “Docherty I have always had in my team because he’s a really good SuperCoach scorer.”
3. Clayton Oliver (Melbourne) MID — “I have always had Clayton Oliver because I love him. He’s fiery and he’s usually pretty good value.”
4. Joe Daniher (Brisbane Lions) FWD — “Even if he just helps me make money for the first (few months) I might be able to make some money and get someone better than him.”
5. Jy Simpkin (North Melbourne) MID — “If there was an unlimited salary cap I would have him in because I think he’s got that sort of grit.”
 
Top