Opinion SC 2021: Rate My Team
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
Hopefully the ones I have picked are the right ones , Brockman could be a issue with Wingard's return.
I am generally an expert at that , having half my bench not playing by Round 4.
Don't they say a no trade side normally outscores the winning side though fairly easily ?
Maybe should just set and forget and come back Round 23 😀
Seriously though the more annoying thing is when 4-6 rookies debut in Round 2.
I guess we just have to make calls on what we have read and researched and back our decisions , if they are wrong try and correct them when and where we can.
Maybe the Clark , Cumming , Daniher , Dow , Impey , Martin , Tyson , Young , Ziebell etc price types will be more important than we think this season.
I am generally an expert at that , having half my bench not playing by Round 4.
Don't they say a no trade side normally outscores the winning side though fairly easily ?
Maybe should just set and forget and come back Round 23 😀
Seriously though the more annoying thing is when 4-6 rookies debut in Round 2.
I guess we just have to make calls on what we have read and researched and back our decisions , if they are wrong try and correct them when and where we can.
Maybe the Clark , Cumming , Daniher , Dow , Impey , Martin , Tyson , Young , Ziebell etc price types will be more important than we think this season.
Caldwell & Cameron have all been on my short list + Bailey , Bolton , Butters , Heeney , Phillips & Ryan.
Bailey is the one I have been ultra keen but probably too scared to start.
In the end I thought might be better to wait and see if any of the above become a must have.
Still think Danger , Dunkley , Dusty , Marshall , Sidey & Zorko will be close to the Top forwards (I guess it then comes down to aggregate v average) so hopefully by starting 3 I am 50% their.
If Daniher starts off with a bang hopefully he is easily upgraded first , Ziebell perhaps does the job until Bye time.
Bailey is the one I have been ultra keen but probably too scared to start.
In the end I thought might be better to wait and see if any of the above become a must have.
Still think Danger , Dunkley , Dusty , Marshall , Sidey & Zorko will be close to the Top forwards (I guess it then comes down to aggregate v average) so hopefully by starting 3 I am 50% their.
If Daniher starts off with a bang hopefully he is easily upgraded first , Ziebell perhaps does the job until Bye time.
- Joined
- 14 May 2015
- Messages
- 2,048
- Likes
- 1,281
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Imo you're a premium short of most good sides I've seen. (Also assuming Rowell becomes a premium scorer). The only explanation I can think of is that you've picked the top-priced premiums in all lines.
Over 25% of your total cash on Lloyd, Neale, Grundy, Danger, not to mention Grundy, Laird, Dunkley and Zerrett not far behind.
Think of your starting cash as an investment; yes of course you need 2-3 SOLID captain choices (investing in points), but then you also need to find a bit of value (stocks rising, ie buy low sell high).
Cripps is a great example in your side as a value-pick. Neale/Lloyd/Gawn/Danger not so much, but a couple of them for captaincy purposes is good.
I think you need to use that 100k cash and some cash generated from downgrading the least likely of those 4-6 top-enders to grab another defensive prem, especially given Jones isn't a likely rd1 starter.
Over 25% of your total cash on Lloyd, Neale, Grundy, Danger, not to mention Grundy, Laird, Dunkley and Zerrett not far behind.
Think of your starting cash as an investment; yes of course you need 2-3 SOLID captain choices (investing in points), but then you also need to find a bit of value (stocks rising, ie buy low sell high).
Cripps is a great example in your side as a value-pick. Neale/Lloyd/Gawn/Danger not so much, but a couple of them for captaincy purposes is good.
I think you need to use that 100k cash and some cash generated from downgrading the least likely of those 4-6 top-enders to grab another defensive prem, especially given Jones isn't a likely rd1 starter.
I think this is where I'm at $33,500 ITB:
Laird, Daniel, Stewart, Short, Clark, Koschitzke (Highmore, Murray)
Macrae, Merrett, Kelly, Dunkley, Heppell, Campbell, Bruhn, Poweel (Sharp, Goulden, Scott)
Gawn, Grundy (Flynn)
Danger, Phillips, Zeibell, Daniher, Dow, Warner (Rowe, Brockman)
Hard to see it getting much better unless Gawn or Grundy are dumped for a rookie R2.
Thoughts?
Laird, Daniel, Stewart, Short, Clark, Koschitzke (Highmore, Murray)
Macrae, Merrett, Kelly, Dunkley, Heppell, Campbell, Bruhn, Poweel (Sharp, Goulden, Scott)
Gawn, Grundy (Flynn)
Danger, Phillips, Zeibell, Daniher, Dow, Warner (Rowe, Brockman)
Hard to see it getting much better unless Gawn or Grundy are dumped for a rookie R2.
Thoughts?
Hi all,
I've been a long time lurker and member and looking forward to getting a bit more involved this year!
I'm currently running with this team and would appreciate any thoughts! My real dilemma at the moment is if I downgrade Neale to Merrett and upgrade Taranto to Cripps or to Dusty to swing him fwd and go a four deep premo Mid. Some rookies pending selection.
LAIRD, DANIEL, STEWART, SHORT, Kosi, Highmore (Sharp, Murray)
NEALE, OLIVER, MACRAE, FYFE, TARANTO, Bruhn, Powell, Gulden (Jordon, Brockman, McNeil)
GAWN, GRUNDY (Flynn)
DANGER, DUNKLEY, Campbell, Warner, Smith, Rowe (Bergman, Scott)
In the bank: $12,500.00
Thanks!
I've been a long time lurker and member and looking forward to getting a bit more involved this year!
I'm currently running with this team and would appreciate any thoughts! My real dilemma at the moment is if I downgrade Neale to Merrett and upgrade Taranto to Cripps or to Dusty to swing him fwd and go a four deep premo Mid. Some rookies pending selection.
LAIRD, DANIEL, STEWART, SHORT, Kosi, Highmore (Sharp, Murray)
NEALE, OLIVER, MACRAE, FYFE, TARANTO, Bruhn, Powell, Gulden (Jordon, Brockman, McNeil)
GAWN, GRUNDY (Flynn)
DANGER, DUNKLEY, Campbell, Warner, Smith, Rowe (Bergman, Scott)
In the bank: $12,500.00
Thanks!
