Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Johnsy44]

Sidebottom vs Zorko

 

[dlanod]

Sidebottom vs Zorko

Obviously a bit late, but I would've gone Sidey.

 

[Albafanclub]

Mills vs Dusty

 

[Leroy]

Mills vs Dusty

Dusty. Stands alone with only a few others as a genuine forward premo. Throw a blanket over Mills and a stack of others to be top defs.

 

[Leroy]

This was a pre-season XvY where I went with option B. It's working ok so far for points on field but is about to cost me a trade of Hunter. Good to reflect!

Neale, Gawn, Daniher, Butts vs
Oliver, Dusty, Ridley, Hunter

 

[Johnsy44]

Bowes vs Mills vs Ridley

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Bowes vs Mills vs Ridley

If you can afford Ridley, him for sure

 

[Inside50]

Bowes vs Mills vs Ridley

I like Bowes as a big POD. Have Ridley though and loving it.

Dusty v Oliver?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Bowes vs Mills vs Ridley

Ridley.
Regretting not sticking with him myself.

 

[PC]

Jones v Fullarton to keep as a rookie fwd?

 

[Tamuhawk]

Jones v Fullarton to keep as a rookie fwd?

Fullarton for dpp.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

Titch vs Boak?

 

[AngryAnt]

Bowes vs Mills vs Ridley

Depends on what you do with the extra $100k with Bowes but out of those three it's got to be Ridley. Looking like a top 3 defender right now.

 

[Darkie]

Titch vs Boak?

Boak is underrated, but Titch is elite.

 

[Montyjnr]

Impey vs Tex

 

[Tamuhawk]

Impey vs Tex

Tex for the quick cash grab.

 

[Backbone]

J Clark/Phillips to Dunkley and McNeil/murray

Or
H young/Phillips to Dunkley and any 123.9k rookie down giro/Evans or lazarro/McNeil/Murray

Ideally having Clark and young at d5/6 is great and the plan was to Turn them into Lloyd and a rookie but with highmore scoring the equal of them I think he’s fine to field over a forward rookie. Also gives me a top 2 forward for the year in Dunkley over a squib in Phillips who won’t get near the top 8.

My gut is telling me to go giro and Dunkley. Giro pod rookie and looked good on the wing. Dunkley enough said. Any input greatly appreciated

I’ve been lucky to avoid Cripps and Neale but Phillips and Taranto are the 2 who are annoying me most. TT survives til the byes I think gotta give him a solid run. His 102 average in 2019 was littered with the odd crap score. It’s how he plays unfortunately

 

[freowho]

J Clark/Phillips to Dunkley and McNeil/murray

Or
H young/Phillips to Dunkley and any 123.9k rookie down giro/Evans or lazarro/McNeil/Murray

Ideally having Clark and young at d5/6 is great and the plan was to Turn them into Lloyd and a rookie but with highmore scoring the equal of them I think he’s fine to field over a forward rookie. Also gives me a top 2 forward for the year in Dunkley over a squib in Phillips who won’t get near the top 8.

My gut is telling me to go giro and Dunkley. Giro pod rookie and looked good on the wing. Dunkley enough said. Any input greatly appreciated

I’ve been lucky to avoid Cripps and Neale but Phillips and Taranto are the 2 who are annoying me most. TT survives til the byes I think gotta give him a solid run. His 102 average in 2019 was littered with the odd crap score. It’s how he plays unfortunately

Phillips and Taranto aren't hurting anyone at their price. If they give you an avenue to a must have then sure, but otherwise I'd let them be. I have Phillips and think he might be my ticket to a ruckmen although that wasn't the original plan.

 

[inwhiterooms]

Dusty vs A. Brayshaw

 

[freowho]

Dusty vs A. Brayshaw

Dusty for fun, Brayshaw probably more solid.