Analysis 2023 Preseason Games

Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,153
AFL Club
Geelong
I think what most are doing is freeing up cash by downgrading Cogs to Gulden, pretty much correlates to Cogs drop in ownership.
Can't fade a guy thats had back to back elite games with higher CBA's, he showed glimpses as early as his draft year.

Sydney got toyed with in the Granny they are bound to make some changes and if Gulden is one I don't want to miss out, he doesnt work you flick him to a Gawn/Trac at position changes probably for 100K.
 
Joined
24 Feb 2015
Messages
6,697
Likes
30,160
AFL Club
Sydney
Can't fade a guy thats had back to back elite games with higher CBA's, he showed glimpses as early as his draft year.

Sydney got toyed with in the Granny they are bound to make some changes and if Gulden is one I don't want to miss out, he doesnt work you flick him to a Gawn/Trac at position changes probably for 100K.
Yeah SuperCoach is a funny game - everyone is quick to jump on those that missed a player that was 'almost guaranteed to break out due to natural progression and increased opportunity' yet ridiculed for 'jumping on a preseason wonder' - it's such an easy game with the benefit of hindsight
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
Can't fade a guy thats had back to back elite games with higher CBA's, he showed glimpses as early as his draft year.

Sydney got toyed with in the Granny they are bound to make some changes and if Gulden is one I don't want to miss out, he doesnt work you flick him to a Gawn/Trac at position changes probably for 100K.
Yeah, it's what I've done too. Fading Cogs, probably not the smartest move, but I see value in Gulden plus the 80k is handy for funding those higher priced rookies.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,034
Likes
57,916
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Gulden will be a very good player if given the right opportunities. Sydney has a few players you can say that about. They can't all get the good roles.

I see improvement from him this year. I don't see him as a must have player, but would definitely keep an eye on him as an early correction if he starts off big.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,153
AFL Club
Geelong
Feel the opposite, helps mitigate the risk if he doesn't pay off and you're not in the minority hurt if he comes out flying.
If he was still under 5% I would pass but the fact that 29% of the comp have him now and realistically most coaches that actually know what they are doing are part of that pack, feels pretty low risk, if he busts you're in the same scenario as majority of the competition.
 
Last edited:
Joined
19 Jan 2016
Messages
1,929
Likes
6,564
If he was still under 5% I would pass but the fact that 29% of the comp have him now and realistically most coaches that actually know what they are doing are part of that pack, feels pretty low risk, if he busts you're in the same scenario as majority of the competition.
Screams of a reactionary movement to a preseason match score, in which he had very atypical CBA attendance and that Callum Mills didn't play in.
 
Joined
18 Sep 2012
Messages
3,404
Likes
7,197
AFL Club
Essendon
Sometimes you can be too stubborn though, thinking that you're too smart to fall for the pre-season hype player. Then they come out averaging 110 in the first month and you're wondering why you didn't just follow the pack. Gulden is getting to that point now where it's probably safer to just pick him.
 
Joined
24 Feb 2015
Messages
6,697
Likes
30,160
AFL Club
Sydney
Sometimes you can be too stubborn though, thinking that you're too smart to fall for the pre-season hype player. Then they come out averaging 110 in the first month and you're wondering why you didn't just follow the pack. Gulden is getting to that point now where it's probably safer to just pick him.
I think it really comes down to structure, He's an awkward price where many will have to shuffle the deck chairs significantly to fit him in and if you're comfortable with your team I'm not sure it's worth it.

As you say, the risk is getting less and less each day starting him. With so many trades and options below his price point to hit that missed mid-price or rookie option like Fyfe, Bruhn, Ziebell, Flanders, Allen etc. I see no issue running him from round 1 unless horse comes out and blatantly says he won't be part of the midfield rotation.
 
Joined
31 Jan 2016
Messages
393
Likes
1,675
Sometimes you can be too stubborn though, thinking that you're too smart to fall for the pre-season hype player. Then they come out averaging 110 in the first month and you're wondering why you didn't just follow the pack. Gulden is getting to that point now where it's probably safer to just pick him.
I'm definitely one who's fallen into the too stubborn basket. That's why this year I picked my first team less than a week before official preseason matches. It's definitely worked, I'm not attached to anyone in my team and have been chopping and changing at will. I'm starting to wonder if it's had the opposite effect and I've become too reactionary. Time will tell.
 
Joined
8 Mar 2012
Messages
638
Likes
1,587
AFL Club
Collingwood
Sometimes you can be too stubborn though, thinking that you're too smart to fall for the pre-season hype player. Then they come out averaging 110 in the first month and you're wondering why you didn't just follow the pack. Gulden is getting to that point now where it's probably safer to just pick him.
Sydney's draw is:
GCS
Haw

Mel
PTA
Ric

You would think that if he keeps up his preseason scores it would be most likely in rounds 1 & 2.
There would be little point bringing him in in Round 3 with a tough run coming up.
To me he is either start him or forget him.
 
Joined
30 Jan 2013
Messages
1,376
Likes
5,070
Sydney's draw is:
GCS
Haw

Mel
PTA
Ric

You would think that if he keeps up his preseason scores it would be most likely in rounds 1 & 2.
There would be little point bringing him in in Round 3 with a tough run coming up.
To me he is either start him or forget him.
This is the type of analysis I don't want to see, putting a torpedo straight into my plan for dealing with him.
 
Top