Discussion 2023: Rate My Team

[Hot Thunder]

Heap of trades to use this year , but the more important thing is will we actually have enough viable downgrade targets during the season to generate the dollars to utilise them fully.

True in what you say but a viable team structure still needs viable premos for bulk of the scoring otherwise you may be left too far behind. I see value picks to be made early and promos who lose value before Rd6 but you still need at least 11 or 12 promos to stay in the hunt early. You could include Gulden as a premo especially if he gets away to a flyer. I think Green is a value premium and should combine beautifully with Callaghan on the outside. Looks like GWS has a good early run. Lots of food for thought but a balanced diet even at this stage would lead to better gut health by rd6. Don’t want indigestion problems by rd3. The balance will give you the cash for the downgraded promos but currently the dilemma is which value picks, mainly mid-priced players deliver the cash for upgrades. I see mid-priced players as anyone higher in price than Ashcroft up to say Gulden if you don’t include him as a possible premium.

 

[Peter56]

I love this team. Now let me ruin it. Gawn to Darcy + McKenzie to Callaghan or Gulden Cogs or Cowan to Coke

I think that Darcey and Callaghan in are the way to go. Thanks 🙂

 

[Manikato1]

This is my "Forgotten Few and Who Knew The New" team.

Made up of players not seen or discussed that often in SCS teams this season, and players who have never played before. Actually think it is not the worst team. Might enter it as the “wife’s team”

 

[randomcliche]

Could we have degeoy in there as well? I know he gets spoke about here, but rarely due to SC scores.... Witts out McIreney in.

Perhaps try and sneak some of Dale, Baker and Saad and Gresham in as well.

Love it!

This is my "Forgotten Few and Who Knew The New" team.

Made up of players not seen or discussed that often in SCS teams this season, and players who have never played before. Actually think it is not the worst team. Might enter it as the “wife’s team”


View attachment 53676

 

[Hot Thunder]

Made up of players not seen or discussed that often in SCS teams this season,

You’ve selected quite a few players that haven’t been talked about yet but you’ve got some that I have considered even in my starting side. I won’t mention rookies as that depends on who gets selected but having a list of alternatives to complete teams helps. They say starting your selections with availed rookies is a way to generate a viable team if you have a structure that you consider will work. I like you choice of Liberatore and Brodie but having the both of them may be too much of a risk. I don’t trust Beveridge and the roles he gives players. Don’t be surprised if he even through Daniels in the ruck while he’s playing mid. Brodie will benefit greatly with more cba time, Mundy not there anymore and the strong possibility of Bradshaw being tagged in early rounds. Tagging in early rounds hasn’t been a norm in past seasons but some of the early teams against Fremantle do tag players. Don’t trust Sinclair’s role under Lyon and the fast ball movement StK are trying to play. Vlastuin has great scoring potential but hasn’t shown anything in pre-season match and still unsure about his role while Day excelled in scoring. He also takes kick outs from goal to boost his scoring. That may also depend on when Salem returns. I like your creativity and it’s possibly the style of team I would strongly considered in the past. My early efforts in SuperCoach reflect that 2019.

 

[Skyline23]

Hi guys, would really appreciate some feedback on my team. Cheers

 

[OnTopBar]

Hi guys, would really appreciate some feedback View attachment 53679 on my team. Cheers

Nothing wrong with that team, I like the Neale, Owens and Cummings picks, bit suss on Petracca but if you're happy then who am I to argue? Rookies are placeholders just hope that you have enough cash to get those Phillips/Sheezel types that could have better job security than the Cincotta/Sturt types.
Good luck.

 

[Shannon]

Freako just posted his final updated round 1 team :-



No Yeo

McLean & Greene at F5/F6

 

[NT.Thunder]

I don't mind the fading of Yeo #justsaying

 

[Under The Dome]

Freako just posted his final updated round 1 team :-

View attachment 53686

No Yeo

McLean & Greene at F5/F6

Left out Mackenzie aswell.
He can swing Dunkley forward for Phillipou, that pushes Greene to the bench and then swap Phillipou for Mackenzie on field.
$56.3k in the bank with those moves.

 

[Santoz]

Freako just posted his final updated round 1 team :-

View attachment 53686

No Yeo

McLean & Greene at F5/F6

Looks pretty G'n'R.

 

[Maccas marvels]

Hi guys, would really appreciate some feedback View attachment 53679 on my team. Cheers

Good team, definately Got the right rookies in there….
only query would be F5 with Owens, cant see him scoring better than Flanders from GC for an extra 7k cost….

 

[Russty_]

I don't mind the fading of Yeo #justsaying

Is it because people are thinking he won't score well or is there some other issue with him?

 

[AbsEZ]

Hey lads, first post, intending to be a more prominent poster on here. Love my team, only issue is, I want Bruhn in for Flanders / maybe even Cogs while flicking Flanders to Sheezel.
10k ITB, no idea how to find the $. Any ideas? Pretty firm on every selection, but feel free to give it a critique, and see if you can find a way to get Bruhn in for Flanders. Cheers

 

[BIGB0Y]

my last draft, im pretty happy with this team i like the balance. happy to take it into round 1. would love some feedback.

 

[Peter56]

Hi guys, would really appreciate some feedback View attachment 53679 on my team. Cheers

Like your team. My only issue would be Petracca. Personally I would go down to Kelly.

 

[AbsEZ]

View attachment 53688
my last draft, im pretty happy with this team i like the balance. happy to take it into round 1. would love some feedback.

Love it mate, back it in for R1!

 

[Professor]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1634793497935990784

View: https://mobile.twitter.com/ItsTheRainman/status/1634793497935990784

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Hey lads, first post, intending to be a more prominent poster on here. Love my team, only issue is, I want Bruhn in for Flanders / maybe even Cogs while flicking Flanders to Sheezel.
10k ITB, no idea how to find the $. Any ideas? Pretty firm on every selection, but feel free to give it a critique, and see if you can find a way to get Bruhn in for Flanders. Cheers

Welcome aboard 👍🏼

Jones to McKenna to raise the Flanders to Bruhn funds perhaps?

 

[Ironhawk]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1634793497935990784

View: https://mobile.twitter.com/ItsTheRainman/status/1634793497935990784

Not a bad way to build a team.