7 points under his starting price when the majority of the alternatives have matched or exceeded theirs. His peers were Macrae, Steele, Lyons, Oliver (not great either), Bont and Fyfe (missed game hurts but was utterly predictable). He's also offered absolutely nothing as a captaincy option which for a super premium starting pick is a major letdown.
Throw in that the reason he's been so bad is the well known lack of golden ticket that has dogged him for years. Last year wasn't him getting a golden ticket but instead seems to be quite clearly a symptom of the shorter quarters.
Positive is he still has time to fix it and his last game was a lot better but to this point he's not been a good pick which in a binary system only leaves the bad pick option.
Sadly, he's not in my 5 worst picks though... Heck I've managed to make 3 trades already that are worse than him as a starting pick