Discussion 2024: Player X v Player Y

[Leroy]

Also Salem vs Oliver for M9 with the news that Salem is out?

What lines do you need them to cover?

If you have Fisher to swap D/F then I'd say neither... get Caldwell instead

 

[Zim^zuM]

L

What lines do you need them to cover?

If you have Fisher to swap D/F then I'd say neither... get Caldwell instead

Looking at Caldwell for F6. Getting too low on trades. Salem was to cover the D/M I have and mids. This week he covers neither though.

I can go up to rankine but then need someone like Crisp or Sicily instead of Sinclair.

 

[Zimmer]

Curnow vs Caldwell?

vs keep Sexton.

Edit: just realised there's a whole discussion in the trade thread.

 

[Peter56]

Who would you trade out?
N Martin or J Steel or J Dawson.

 

[Zimmer]

Curnow vs Caldwell?

vs keep Sexton.

Edit: just realised there's a whole discussion in the trade thread.

Any thoughts on the Sexton equation?

 

[Zimmer]

Who would you trade out?
N Martin or J Steel or J Dawson.

Sot of depends who you’re looking to trade in…

 

[Zim^zuM]

Sot of depends who you’re looking to trade in…

After tonight Martin looks like good trade bait.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Who's more likely to get the lower score this week? Miller vs Rozee.

 

[FlatTrackBully]

Who's more likely to get the lower score this week? Miller vs Rozee.

Both teams have been quite restrictive to midfielders but I think I'd back in Miller against North who I doubt tag him, Rowell was tagged last time by Phillips so should be fine on that front. Flip a coin though really, at the end of the day there's probably 10 points in it.

 

[zac-ster]

Shoenmacher Vs Evans?

 

[Tamuhawk]

Who's more likely to get the lower score this week? Miller vs Rozee.

Omg...

I put the E on the wrong one. What a terrible 50/50 loss.

 

[Under The Dome]

English + LDU
vs
TDK + Caldwell
vs
Marshall + Neale

 

[Shannon]

English + LDU
vs
TDK + Caldwell
vs
Marshall + Neale

Marshall + Neale

 

[Miller is a Steele]

English + LDU
vs
TDK + Caldwell
vs
Marshall + Neale

I vote for Marshall + Neale too.

 

[gilly]

Neale vs Dunkley vs Merett?

 

[Russty_]

Neale vs Dunkley vs Merett?

I would say Merrett first, Dunkley second and Neale third, just because of his age I guess, I brought Dunks in last week on the back of two 140 plus scores and then he delivered a third for me.

 

[SCNuffie]

Sam De Koning vs Bailey Dale ? SDK looking good in the ruck, pretty strong last few games (minus the 64). frees up about $120k to fix other fires

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Sam De Koning vs Bailey Dale ? SDK looking good in the ruck, pretty strong last few games (minus the 64). frees up about $120k to fix other fires

I’d go SDK. All depends on if the ruck role sticks or not but I’m confident he’ll hold it. Large amount of excess cash too which could be very handy down the track.

 

[dlanod]

Cameron v Moore v Simpkin (Fisher replacement).

 

[Brookesy]

Who to trade, Sexton or Fisher? Have to trade one to avoid a donut as I'm copping all of Touk, Gawn, Heeney, Rankine, Sexton and Fisher this week.

Fisher frees up more cash, but there's still a fair chunk of the season to go and I'll be down to 2 trades, so should also be taking into consideration the most likely to actually get back into the 22 for their teams.