Position Midfielder Discussion

Who are your likely 3 starters post Marsh 1...?

  • Macrae

    Votes: 73 69.5%
  • Neale

    Votes: 56 53.3%
  • Fyfe

    Votes: 21 20.0%
  • Kelly

    Votes: 24 22.9%
  • Cripps

    Votes: 57 54.3%
  • Dunkley

    Votes: 26 24.8%
  • Titch

    Votes: 19 18.1%
  • Danger

    Votes: 25 23.8%
  • Bont

    Votes: 25 23.8%
  • Oliver

    Votes: 35 33.3%

  • Total voters
    105
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
4,389
Likes
3,913
AFL Club
Fremantle
I think Viney is being judged a bit harshly. I read he got tagged by Curnow in his last game. Burgess seems to have whipped Melbourne into shape. Viney, Oliver and Petracca looking like the preferred mids. I still think he can be a good value M7 or M8 and I can see more value in upgrading elsewhere for the moment.
 
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
2,591
Likes
1,615
AFL Club
West Coast
I think Viney is being judged a bit harshly. I read he got tagged by Curnow in his last game. Burgess seems to have whipped Melbourne into shape. Viney, Oliver and Petracca looking like the preferred mids. I still think he can be a good value M7 or M8 and I can see more value in upgrading elsewhere for the moment.
I think Viney is being judged a bit harshly. I read he got tagged by Curnow in his last game. Burgess seems to have whipped Melbourne into shape. Viney, Oliver and Petracca looking like the preferred mids. I still think he can be a good value M7 or M8 and I can see more value in upgrading elsewhere for the moment.
yep, tagged 1st half of the game.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (Rd3= 20 CBA):
R O’Brien: 64/72
M Crouch: 42/72
B Crouch: 39/72
R Sloane: 35/72
B Smith: 24/72
P Seedsman: 19/72
C Jones: 18/72
R Atkins: 15/72
B Keays: 9/72
B Frampton: 5/72
N McHenry: 5/72
D Fogarty: 3/72
T Walker: 2/72
RD4 CBA- https://www.afl.com.au/news/459321/fantasy-secrets-to-success-every-club-s-cbas-for-r4
Reminder that the following for each club provided in the posts below doesn't take into account the matches missed by each player.

Adelaide:
After RD4 (RD4= 21 CBA)
93 CBA
R O'Brien= 84
R Sloane: 52
B Crouch: 51
M Crouch: 42
B Keays: 28
C Jones: 26
P Seedsman: 19
R Atkins: 15
M Poholke: 7
B Frampton: 6
N McHenry: 5
D Fogarty: 3
T Walker: 2
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 19 CBA)
L Neale: 66/69
J Lyons: 51/69
O McInerney: 45/69
D Zorko: 24/69
H McCluggage: 21/69
S Martin: 18/69
J Berry: 14/69
C Rayner: 14/69
C Ellis-Yolmen: 11/69
A Smith: 6/69
L McCarthy: 2/69
D Robertson: 2/69
M Robinson: 2/69
Brisbane:
After RD4 (RD4= 21 CBA):
90 CBA
L Neale: 87
J Lyons: 66
O McInerney: 58
J Berry: 25
D Zorko: 25
C Ellis-Yolmen: 21
H McCluggage: 21
C Rayner: 19
S Martin: 18
A Smith: 14
L McCarthy: 2
D Robertson: 2
M Robinson: 2
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 27 CBA)
E Curnow: 72/78
P Cripps: 72/78
M Pittonet: 40/78
M Murphy: 33/78
L Casboult: 28/78
J Martin: 27/78
Z Fisher: 10/78
W Setterfield: 10/78
M Kreuzer: 8/78
S Walsh: 7/78
D Cunningham: 3/78
M McGovern: 2/78
Carlton:
After RD4 (RD4= 18 CBA):
96 CBA
P Cripps: 88
E Curnow: 87
M Pittonet: 56
M Murphy: 34
J Martin: 33
L Casboult: 30
W Setterfield: 17
Z Fisher: 10
S Walsh: 10
D Cunningham: 9
M Kreuzer: 8
M McGovern: 2
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 20 CBA )
B Grundy: 50/56
T Adams: 45/56
S Pendlebury: 41/56
J DeGoey: 39/56
T Brown: 16/56
R Wills: 13/56
J Elliott: 12/56
D Cameron: 3/56
M Cox: 3/56
C Brown: 1/56
S Sidebottom: 1/56
Collingwood:
After RD4 (RD4= 23 CBA):
79 CBA
B Grundy: 70
T Adams: 62
S Pendlebury: 58
J De Goey: 48
R Wills: 26
T Brown: 16
M Cox: 6
S Sidebottom: 6
D Cameron: 3
C Brown: 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
2020 Centre Bounce Attendances (CBA) after RD2:
Essendon (RD1= 21 + RD2=26 =47):
T Bellchambers: 44/47
D Shiel: 40/47
A McGrath: 32/47
J Stringer: 29/47
A McDonald-Tipungwuti: 12/47
Z Merrett: 11/47
D Parish: 8/47
D Smith: 8/47
K Langford: 3/47
J Townsend: 1/47
Essendon:
After RD4 (RD4= 18 CBA):
65 CBA
T Bellchambers: 59
D Shiel: 53
A McGrath: 45
J Stringer: 39
Z Merrett: 17
D Smith: 14
A McDonald-Tipungwuti: 14
D Parish: 8
K Langford: 7
S McKernan: 3
J Townsend: 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 20 CBA)
N Fyfe: 51/65
D Tucker: 38/65
M Walters: 34/65
R Lobb: 32/65
S Darcy: 30/65
A Brayshaw: 23/65
D Mundy: 22/65
A Cerra: 20/65
M Crowden: 7/65
M Tabener: 3/65
Fremantle:
After RD4 (RD4= 22 CBA):
87 CBA
N Fyfe: 65
D Tucker: 54
R Lobb: 51
M Walters: 46
D Mundy: 35
S Darcy: 30
A Brayshaw: 24
A Cerra: 20
C Serong: 10
M Crowden: 7
M Tabener: 6
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 27 CBA)
P Dangerfield: 70/87
J Selwood: 64/87
Q Narkle: 48/87
R Stanley: 44/87
C Guthrie: 32/87
D Fort: 26/87
M Duncan: 16/87
E Ratugolea: 14/87
B Parfitt: 13/87
T Atkins: 6/87
J Steven: 5/87
G Ablett: 3/87
M Blicavs: 3/60
S Menegola: 3/87
L Dahlhaus: 1/87
Geelong:
After RD4 (RD4= 17 CBA):
104 CBA
P Dangerfield: 84
J Selwood: 81
Q Narkle: 48
R Stanley: 44
D Fort: 36
C Guthrie: 33
M Duncan: 27
E Ratugloea: 21
B Parfitt: 20
T Atkins: 6
J Steven: 6
G Ablett: 3
M Blicavs: 3
S Menegola: 3
L Dahlhaus: 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 20 CBA)
J Witts: 53/62
H Greenwood: 43/62
M Rowell: 40/62
T Miller: 38/62
L Weller: 37/62
S Day: 9/62
D Swallow: 9/62
W Brodie: 6/62
B Fiorini: 5/62
N Holman: 5/62
D MacPherson: 2/62
S Lemmens: 1/62
Gold Coast:
After RD4 (RD= 22 CBA)
84 CBA
J Witts: 73
H Greenwood: 58
M Rowell: 55
T Miller: 52
L Weller: 51
D Swallow: 17
S Day: 11
W Brodie: 6
B Fiorini: 5
N Holman: 5
D MacPherson: 2
S Lemmens: 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 15 CBA)
S Jacobs: 61/71
M De Boer= 59/71
J Hopper= 54/71
S Coniglio= 42/71
J Kelly: 22/71
T Green: 16/71
C Ward: 11/71
J Finlayson: 10/71
J Caldwell: 7/71
T Greene: 2/71
GWS:
After RD4 (RD4= 23 CBA)
94 CBA
M DeBoer: 71
J Hopper: 69
S Jacobs: 61
S Conglio: 53
J Kelly: 31
T Green: 24
C Ward: 24
S Mumford: 19
J Finlayson: 14
J Caldwell: 7
T Greene: 2
B Daniels: 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 19 CBA)
J Ceglar: 59/73
T Mitchell: 58/73
J Worpel: 50/73
J O'Meara: 33/73
L Shiels: 33/73
C Wingard: 26/73
T O’Brien: 10/73
S Burgoyne: 8/73
L Breust: 7/73
B McEvoy: 4/73
P Puopolo: 2/73
R Henderson: 1/73
I Smith: 1/73
Hawthorn:
After RD4 (RD4= 20 CBA)
93 CBA
J Ceglar 76
T Mitchell 75
J Worpel 61
J O'Meara 49
L Shiels 38
C Wingard 32
S Burgoyne 12
T O'Brien 12
L Bruest 8
B McEvoy 4
P Puopolo 2
R Henderson 1
M Lewis 1
I Smith 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
2020 Centre Bounce Attendances (CBA) after RD2:
Melbourne (RD1= 23 + RD2=19 =42):
M Gawn: 40/42
C Oliver: 37/42
J Viney: 32/42
C Petracca: 31/42
A Brayshaw: 24/42
N Jones: 2/42
L Jackson: 1/42
T McDonald: 1/42
Melbourne:
After RD4 (RD4= 17 CBA)
59 CBA
M Gawn 57
C Oliver 50
J Viney 48
C Petracca 40
A Brayshaw 35
J Harmes 2
N Jones 2
L Jackson 1
T McDonald 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 22 CBA)
T Goldstein: 64/65
J Simpkin: 49/65
S Higgins: 41/65
B Cunnington: 38/65
J Anderson: 26/65
A Hall: 20/65
T Thomas: 10/65
J Ziebell: 7/65
C Zurhaar: 3/65
A Bonar: 1/65
J Polec: 1/65
NM:
After RD 4 (RD4= 20 CBA)
85 CBA
T Goldstein 83
J Simpkin 66
S Higgins 60
B Cunnington 36
J Anderson 34
A Hall 25
J Ziebell 12
T Thomas 11
J Polec 6
C Zurhaar 3
A Bonar 1
T Xerri 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 20 CBA)
S Lycett: 53/64
T Boak: 52/64
T Rockliff: 51/64
D Houston: 20/64
C Rozee: 18/64
S Powell-Pepper: 17/64
O Wines: 16/64
J Westhoff: 11/64
R Gray: 9/64
K Amon: 7/64
B Ebert: 2/64
Port:
After RD4 (RD4= 22 CBA)
86 CBA
S Lycett 73
T Boak 66
T Rockliff 61
O Wines 32
C Rozee 30
S Powell- Pepper 24
D Houston 20
R Gray 15
J Westhoff 13
K Amon 8
B Ebert 2
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 19 CBA)
T Cotchin: 51/65
D Prestia: 47/65
I Soldo: 45/65
D Martin: 30/65
S Edwards: 28/65
T Nankervis: 16/65
M Pickett: 14/65
K Lambert: 10/65
J Ross: 10/65
J Graham: 3/65
T Lynch: 2/65
N Broad: 1/65
J Caddy: 1/65
S Bolton: 1/65
S Stack: 1/65
After RD4 (RD4= 29 CBA)
94 CBA
D Prestia 72
T Cotchin 71
S Edwards 46
D Martin 45
I Soldo 45
T Nankervis 39
K Lambert 14
M Pickett 14
J Ross 11
K McIntosh 4
S Bolton 3
N Broad 3
J Graham 3
T Lynch 2
N Vlatsuin 2
J Caddy 1
S Stack 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 20 CBA)
J Steele: 48/64
Z Jones: 42/64
P Ryder: 39/64
J Gresham: 31/64
S Ross: 29/64
R Marshall: 25/64
L Dunstan: 13/64
D Hannebery: 11/64
H Clark: 8/64
J Marsh: 6/64
J Billings: 1/64
B Hill: 1/64
D Kent: 1/64
T Membrey: 1/64
StK:
After RD4 (RD4= 29 CBA)
93 CBA
J Steele 68
Z Jones 57
S Ross 53
R Marshall 51
J Gresham 41
P Ryder 39
D Hannebery 24
L Dunstan 13
J Marsh 9
H Clark 8
J Battle 3
J Billings 2
B Hill 2
D Kent 1
T Membrey 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 22 CBA)
L Parker: 61/74
O Florent: 58/74
J Kennedy: 56/74
C Sinclair: 41/74
J Rowbottom: 35/74
S Naismith: 22/74
A Allir: 8/74
G Hewett: 7/74
I Heeney: 3/74
H McLean: 3/74
T Papley: 2/74
Sydney:
After RD4 (RD4= 19 CBA)
93 CBA
L Parker 75
O Florent 71
J Kennedy 71
C Sinclair 46
J Rowbottom 40
S Naismith 36
C Mills 9
A Allir 8
G Hewett 7
I Heeney 3
H McLean 3
T Papley 2
L Taylor 1
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
After RD3 (RD3= 15 CBA)
M Bontempelli: 54/62
J Dunkley: 50/62
T English: 50/62
B Smith: 43/62
J Macrae: 32/62
J Bruce: 9/62
P Lipinski: 4/62
M Wallis: 3/62
L Young: 3/62
WB:
After RD4 (RD4= 19 CBA)
81 CBA
M Bontempelli 72
T English 69
B Smith 61
J Dunkley 50
J Macrae 47
J Bruce 9
T Liberatore 5
P Lipinski 4
M Wallis 3
T McLean 1
L Young 1
 
Top