Opinion Player X vs Player Y

[bomberboy]

Gotta be Dahl. Can't pick finishing premiums based on a good 3 week draw

Agreed. Sometimes you just gotta go with the obvious pick.

 

[Spud]

Suckling V B. Reid

 

[MrMurdoch]

Suckling V B. Reid

Suckers for me. Done well since Murphy went down

 

[jbar]

Docherty vs Simmo and cash vs laird/rance and more cash??

 

[Eagling]

Docherty vs Simmo and cash vs laird/rance and more cash??

Rance>Laird>Simpson>Docherty

 

[lavenderbandit]

Heath Shaw vs no Heath Shaw in my final side.

In order to get him in >$600k I am going to have to wait until after round 15'ish without ruining my other plans to complete my side earlier. But a final Defensive line without him looks poor.

I think I already know the answer, but its just so hard to get him in at a massive price for a defender without moving heaven and earth and compromising my other trades

 

[Brettthejett]

Heath Shaw vs no Heath Shaw in my final side.

In order to get him in >$600k I am going to have to wait until after round 15'ish without ruining my other plans to complete my side earlier. But a final Defensive line without him looks poor.

I think I already know the answer, but its just so hard to get him in at a massive price for a defender without moving heaven and earth and compromising my other trades

There it is

 

[meataxe]

I'm short $10k for Selwood, but can afford Rockliff.

A: wait 1 round for Selwood (ie spend this round upgrading Kerridge to Dahlhaus)

B: go for Rockliff

 

[lavenderbandit]

There it is

Haha cheers. Probably over thinking it. Sometimes you just gotta pay top dollar

 

[meataxe]

Heath Shaw vs no Heath Shaw in my final side.

In order to get him in >$600k I am going to have to wait until after round 15'ish without ruining my other plans to complete my side earlier. But a final Defensive line without him looks poor.

I think I already know the answer, but its just so hard to get him in at a massive price for a defender without moving heaven and earth and compromising my other trades

Shaw is too expensive at the moment. Focus on upgrading other parts of your team for now, you just need to hope that a 65 point game happens soon to drag his price back to around $550k or less.

 

[Prochard]

Last minute tips on
Deledio vs Dahlhaus?

Confident in Deledio to score better even taking into account the possibility of missing a game.
However, Dahlhaus is cheaper and fits my bye structure a tiny bit better. (20 in round 13 & 20 in round 14 instead of 19 in round 13 & 21, meaning I don't have to take Tucker's score in either round 13 or 14)

Cheers

 

[Feerits Elf]

Here's an interesting quandary.

Option 1

D: Shaw, Docherty, Boyd, Rance, Bartel, McVeigh
M: Dangerfield, Hannebery, Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Naitanui

Option 2

D: Shaw, Rance, Bartel, Laird, McVeigh, Rich
M: Dangerfield, Hannebery, Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Gawn

Option 3

D: Shaw, Boyd, Rance, Bartel, Laird, McVeigh
M: Dangerfield, Pendlebury, Ablett, Parker, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Gawn

Not keen on holding Naitanui because of question marks over his Achilles.

But if I hold him as R2 I can significantly improve my backline with Docherty and Boyd.

If I move him on for Gawn, I have to take Laird and Rich (but I can still take Hannebery).

If I take Gawn and someone like Parker (passing on Hannebery), I can take Boyd instead of Rich.

What do, supercoachscores?

 

[Brettthejett]

Feerits Elf ideally you would want Boyd Laird Hanners Gawn I wouldn't personally touch Docherty at his price he doesn't have a history of such high scoring but is very tempting and i get why you have him there.
I think his horse bolted

 

[Feerits Elf]

Feerits Elf ideally you would want Boyd Laird Hanners Gawn I wouldn't personally touch Docherty at his price he doesn't have a history of such high scoring but is very tempting and i get why you have him there.
I think his horse bolted

Docherty would be post-bye when he is projected to be sub-$550k. Alternatively Simpson.

As shown above, Boyd/Laird/Hannebery/Gawn is not achievable (would have to take Parker in lieu of Hannebery).

 

[IDIG]

Last minute tips on
Deledio vs Dahlhaus?

Confident in Deledio to score better even taking into account the possibility of missing a game.
However, Dahlhaus is cheaper and fits my bye structure a tiny bit better. (20 in round 13 & 20 in round 14 instead of 19 in round 13 & 21, meaning I don't have to take Tucker's score in either round 13 or 14)

Cheers

Tough one. I think your bye stats and likely game missed for Lids has me favouring Dahl. I do like Lids though, would be a handy pod.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

I'm short $10k for Selwood, but can afford Rockliff.

A: wait 1 round for Selwood (ie spend this round upgrading Kerridge to Dahlhaus)

B: go for Rockliff

In your case, I would go Rockliff

 

[Darkie]

Here's an interesting quandary.

Option 1

D: Shaw, Docherty, Boyd, Rance, Bartel, McVeigh
M: Dangerfield, Hannebery, Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Naitanui

Option 2

D: Shaw, Rance, Bartel, Laird, McVeigh, Rich
M: Dangerfield, Hannebery, Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Gawn

Option 3

D: Shaw, Boyd, Rance, Bartel, Laird, McVeigh
M: Dangerfield, Pendlebury, Ablett, Parker, Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Rockliff
R: Goldstein, Gawn

Not keen on holding Naitanui because of question marks over his Achilles.

But if I hold him as R2 I can significantly improve my backline with Docherty and Boyd.

If I move him on for Gawn, I have to take Laird and Rich (but I can still take Hannebery).

If I take Gawn and someone like Parker (passing on Hannebery), I can take Boyd instead of Rich.

What do, supercoachscores?

Option one, especially if it saves you a trade. I'd do NN to Gawn only if a proper injury strikes, not pre-emptively.

Also, I'd seriously consider Laird over Doc. Simpson is probably better again.

 

[meataxe]

From best to worst, out of Selwood, R Gray, Ward, Priddis?

Selwood is the logical one to be best, but I think Geelong will "rest" him in at least one of the last 4 easy games (Essendon, Richmond, Brisbane, Melbourne).

 

[MrMurdoch]

From best to worst, out of Selwood, R Gray, Ward, Priddis?

Selwood is the logical one to be best, but I think Geelong will "rest" him in at least one of the last 4 easy games (Essendon, Richmond, Brisbane, Melbourne).

Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Ward for me

 

[Ben's Beasts]

From best to worst, out of Selwood, R Gray, Ward, Priddis?

Selwood is the logical one to be best, but I think Geelong will "rest" him in at least one of the last 4 easy games (Essendon, Richmond, Brisbane, Melbourne).

Selwood a clear best of the four. Hard to split the others.

I wouldn't not pick him because of the slight chance he is rested late in the season.