Opinion Player X vs Player Y

[meataxe]

Selwood, Priddis, Gray, Ward for me

Selwood a clear best of the four. Hard to split the others.

I wouldn't not pick him because of the slight chance he is rested late in the season.

Thanks for that.

Sometimes we can overcomplicate things in this game - the logical trades are typically the best ones.

 

[anfa18]

Smith vs Davis on field

 

[30BucketsofRo]

Smith vs Davis on field

Smithers

 

[Zimmer]

Parker v Selwood

 

[Rowsus]

Parker v Selwood

Selwood. Parker hasn't really proven himself to be a genuine 110+ player yet.

 

[Imcjb]

will need to save up for Docherty it seems or wait patiently for him to go down. For the other spot in defence, Rance vs Gibson?

 

[Eagling]

will need to save up for Docherty it seems or wait patiently for him to go down. For the other spot in defence, Rance vs Gibson?

Rance by the length of a straight.

 

[bloke]

Promise this is the last question I ask this week

Greene + Trengove + Hipwood vs. Merrett + Reid + bottom pricer

Won't be getting Hipwood/rookie till round 10, other two this week. In both scenarios I have Petracca in the forwards and a DPP link to allow him to allow him to cover any mid outs

 

[Bomber18]

Promise this is the last question I ask this week

Greene + Trengove + Hipwood vs. Merrett + Reid + bottom pricer

Won't be getting Hipwood/rookie till round 10, other two this week. In both scenarios I have Petracca in the forwards and a DPP link to allow him to allow him to cover any mid outs

Trengrove option for sure.

 

[bloke]

Trengrove option for sure.

Thanks Bomber. I was leaning that way, I need to stop getting swayed so easily love your work

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Hold Keays this week with a BE of 56, gives me another player on field for the week.

VS.

Hold Davis instead, even though he has the bye this week, has the BE of 35.

Essentially, which one to hold and which one to trade.

 

[bloke]

Hold Keays this week with a BE of 56, gives me another player on field for the week.

VS.

Hold Davis instead, even though he has the bye this week, has the BE of 35.

Essentially, which one to hold and which one to trade.

I still think we can squeeze 20k out of Davis, I'm holding him until at least round 15.

Who will play this week instead of Keays?
It pretty much comes down to whoever plays instead of Keays + Davis score next week vs. Keays this week and next (this is of course assuming you trade them both out by round 15 which you might not)

 

[minidee]

I still think we can squeeze 20k out of Davis, I'm holding him until at least round 10.

Who will play this week instead of Keays?
It pretty much comes down to whoever plays instead of Keays + Davis score next week vs. Keays this week and next (this is of course assuming you trade them both out by round 10 which you might not)

We're up to round 13, which round do you mean?

 

[bloke]

We're up to round 13, which round do you mean?

Round 15 haha.

I'm still living in 2014 when the byes were rounds 8, 9 and 10

 

[freowho]

Hold Keays this week with a BE of 56, gives me another player on field for the week.

VS.

Hold Davis instead, even though he has the bye this week, has the BE of 35.

Essentially, which one to hold and which one to trade.

If you can hold Davis and still field 19 players he will help you in the next 2 weeks and I would trade Keays. I think only fielding 18 players is asking for trouble.

 

[Johnsy44]

Rose Vs Reid
Who has better js

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Rose Vs Reid
Who has better js

Rose for me, too much competition at GWS

 

[Johnsy44]

Rose for me, too much competition at GWS

Cheers mate, how about Hams?

 

[Prochard]

Stewart vs Jansen?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Thoughts on...

Zac Merrett vs. Dayne Zorko (vs. Deledio)

So the plan for the last 5 weeks has been to get in Dahlhaus this week, however, due to the events of last week that will obviously not be happening.

Anyone have the numbers on how many centre bounces Zorko attended last week?? Because from memory, the week before he didn't have any centre bounce attendances. That was the week Rocky and Jansen came in.