Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,963
- Likes
- 126,630
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
A rookie related Player X VS Player Y decision.
Dependent on team selections for this round and next round with 1 rookie grabbed this week replacing N Answerth and 1 next week replacing W Setterfield to occupy M9 and M10 likely for the remainder of the season or to establish cover (eg Menegola selected for C Burgess).
B Bewley
VS
N Hind
VS
D Clarke
VS
J Hately.
Preference would be B Bewley this round and D Clarke next week but would greatly appreciate any advice.
Dependent on team selections for this round and next round with 1 rookie grabbed this week replacing N Answerth and 1 next week replacing W Setterfield to occupy M9 and M10 likely for the remainder of the season or to establish cover (eg Menegola selected for C Burgess).
B Bewley
VS
N Hind
VS
D Clarke
VS
J Hately.
Preference would be B Bewley this round and D Clarke next week but would greatly appreciate any advice.
I'm doing exactly what you're doing.
There's enough evidence to show why Hately won't be a good rookie. There's been plenty of chances to Cameron to bring him in and he's chosen others despite good form.
Hind is every chance of playing well, but he's only gotten a game because the saints have multiple injuries and there are others to come back.
I'll always opt to grab a player on the bubble as well because I feel like the risk is reduced.
There's enough evidence to show why Hately won't be a good rookie. There's been plenty of chances to Cameron to bring him in and he's chosen others despite good form.
Hind is every chance of playing well, but he's only gotten a game because the saints have multiple injuries and there are others to come back.
I'll always opt to grab a player on the bubble as well because I feel like the risk is reduced.
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Maybe not ideal, however, you can see game 2 of Clarke and game 1 of Hind. Unless both smash it, you go Bewley. If both do smash it, you make the call to not take Bewley for the longer term benefit of team.
Just not sure Bewley can survive on HFF if Bennell comes back into side. Hill into the side any mid time that Bewley needs is becoming less and less.
Just not sure Bewley can survive on HFF if Bennell comes back into side. Hill into the side any mid time that Bewley needs is becoming less and less.
