Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Herbie66]

Yeah, that's why I'm gambling.

I did compile a quick chart of OMac's CBA versus SC Scoring

View attachment 19664

The idea is to get him sub $400k for hopefully a 90+ average; the alternative would be to wait for Greenwood down the line who might get to $500k and with cash gen so hard I figured I might as well take the risk and finish my forward line.

Good table , thanks for sharing.

Last 2-3 games certainly indicates a upside , just hope he maintains it.

I am have been watching his scores the last few weeks so going to take the punt.

Now have 4 x F/R so plenty of flexibility.

Watching Draper last night if he removed the FA from his game he could be capable of 85-90 ish scores himself so gives me the added option of using him as a R2 if necessary as well.

 

[Adrenaline]

I am not sure who I should trade in out of Ridley, Maynard, Daniel Or L Ryan

 

[Ironhawk]

I am not sure who I should trade in out of Ridley, Maynard, Daniel Or L Ryan

Ridley has the best average, has had his bye, but also some doubt on his fitness.
Maynard is cheapest and has the second best average
Daniel is reasonably consistent, 2nd highest price and still has a bye to come.
Ryan has had his bye and is most expensive with the lowest average overall but good recent form.

If named, Ridley is the best pick for me. Daniel would be locked out by the time you find out if he is playing, I would probably prefer Ryan over Maynard if Ridley misses this round.

 

[jel]

If there’s a decent chance of not ending up with the second one, I’d definitely get Titch this week. He is SuperCoach royalty and Shuey is basically a 90s player historically.

I'm firming on Titch atm.
Also, if Shuey goes up in price as expected, he is very close to Adams, who looks like a better prospect this year.

 

[Darkie]

I'm firming on Titch atm.
Also, if Shuey goes up in price as expected, he is very close to Adams, who looks like a better prospect this year.

Just locked in Titch myself. Did not seriously consider Shuey, but did consider Adams.

 

[Adrenaline]

Ridley has the best average, has had his bye, but also some doubt on his fitness.
Maynard is cheapest and has the second best average
Daniel is reasonably consistent, 2nd highest price and still has a bye to come.
Ryan has had his bye and is most expensive with the lowest average overall but good recent form.

If named, Ridley is the best pick for me. Daniel would be locked out by the time you find out if he is playing, I would probably prefer Ryan over Maynard if Ridley misses this round.

Thanks mate for your advice. I might wait a week and bring in dusty

 

[Steuby]

Big O vs Simpkin for F6

 

[Ironhawk]

Big O vs Simpkin for F6

See #1557.

 

[pizza safety]

Titch vs Fyfe? Fyfe only has another 8 games

 

[Ironhawk]

Titch vs Fyfe? Fyfe only has another 8 games

Both only have 8 games. I'm biased but would pick Titch. Fyfe coming back from injury always worries me. Both can score very well fully fit, thinking Titch might be the fitter of the two right now. Fyfe also has a 150+ BE, compared to 75 for Titch.

 

[Darkie]

Both only have 8 games. I'm biased but would pick Titch. Fyfe coming back from injury always worries me. Both can score very well fully fit, thinking Titch might be the fitter of the two right now. Fyfe also has a 150+ BE, compared to 75 for Titch.

Agree with this. Titch more durable and averaging 114 without playing particularly well.

 

[Slammer]

Duncan vs Adams

 

[Ironhawk]

Duncan vs Adams

Usually these two are similar scoring players, I think with a few extra injuries at Collingwood that Adams will be getting a bit more of it in the next few weeks which gives him a slight edge. Both look good for consistent 100+ scores though.

 

[Darkie]

Duncan vs Adams

A pretty close one. I’d take Duncan narrowly, unless Adams is materially better for you from a bye perspective.

 

[JoeyRulz]

Simpson -> Titch vs Bennell -> Shuey

 

[Ironhawk]

Simpson -> Titch vs Bennell -> Shuey

You'll possibly be cashing out Simpson early, with a BE of 21. Bennell is basically maxed and not named - he's not going to make any more cash, just a bench clogger. If you can get Titch in another way rather than sacrificing Simpson, I'd be looking at that option, as I would expect Mitchell to outperform Shuey for the rest of the season by 10 or more points per match on current form. If you can't, do the Simpson -> Titch option, and plan on the best way to get rid of Bennell in another trade.

 

[JoeyRulz]

You'll possibly be cashing out Simpson early, with a BE of 21. Bennell is basically maxed and not named - he's not going to make any more cash, just a bench clogger. If you can get Titch in another way rather than sacrificing Simpson, I'd be looking at that option, as I would expect Mitchell to outperform Shuey for the rest of the season by 10 or more points per match on current form. If you can't, do the Simpson -> Titch option, and plan on the best way to get rid of Bennell in another trade.

Cheers. Cash generation is becoming an issue for my team. Only have 3 more spots to fill, but I’ll need to trade 3 rookies to get 1 premium. Might just lock in Titch this round, and look at cheap alternatives for the last 2 spots (like Kennedy - swans, maybe even Shuey next week).

 

[pizza safety]

Both only have 8 games. I'm biased but would pick Titch. Fyfe coming back from injury always worries me. Both can score very well fully fit, thinking Titch might be the fitter of the two right now. Fyfe also has a 150+ BE, compared to 75 for Titch.

I know both have 8 games I meant that theres less time for Fyfe to get injured, he only needs to get through another 8 games without getting injured. Titch definitely hasn't looked himself until last week and hasn't shown much of a second gear, for some reason I feel like Fyfe has the bigger ceiling with this years scoring but Titch is the safer of the two picks though and the one I'll very likely go for.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

I know both have 8 games I meant that theres less time for Fyfe to get injured, he only needs to get through another 8 games without getting injured. Titch definitely hasn't looked himself until last week and hasn't shown much of a second gear, for some reason I feel like Fyfe has the bigger ceiling with this years scoring but Titch is the safer of the two picks though and the one I'll very likely go for.

I used that logic when I brought in Fyfe two games before his last injury. Role is somewhat of a concern where he is now playing more mid time and some time forward. may be just a fitness issue, high BE, can afford to wait I think.

 

[Deeman1]

Fyfe v TKelly v Gaff?