Opinion Round 2: Captain and Vice Captain Selections
- Thread starter Erich1036
- Start date
- Joined
- 17 Jun 2014
- Messages
- 9,618
- Likes
- 37,716
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I only have Grimely as a loophole option, so can only take a VC option tomorrow night ... So looking like Rance as my only premo playing, so unlikely to be used (will be a massive POD if I do get to call on him though!) then probably Goldy as C .... Surely Danger can't go massive back to back? So I'm leaning to Goldy.
In the past couple of seasons, Goldstein's three battles with Stef Martin have gone: 127, 154 & 122.
Gawn has only scored above 122 twice in his career. I will concede that one of those was a 150 against the Bombers last year, where he dominated the hitouts 58 to Shaun McKernan's 20, however he will be facing Leuey this time around so we won't expect as one-sided a performance.
I guess a lot of Gawn's points come from his work around the ground, so my argument is less valid, but that's my 2 cents.
Gawn has only scored above 122 twice in his career. I will concede that one of those was a 150 against the Bombers last year, where he dominated the hitouts 58 to Shaun McKernan's 20, however he will be facing Leuey this time around so we won't expect as one-sided a performance.
I guess a lot of Gawn's points come from his work around the ground, so my argument is less valid, but that's my 2 cents.
Injury cloud hangs over Scott Pendlebury heading into Richmond clash
Date
March 31, 2016 - 7:12PM
Read later
inShare
submit to reddit
Scott Pendlebury will be crucial to Collingwood's chances.
Scott Pendlebury will be crucial to Collingwood's chances.
Collingwood captain Scott Pendlebury will carry sore ribs into Friday night's blockbuster against Richmond, says Sam 'Scoop' McClure.
The Sports Today newsbreaker said the Magpie superstar wasn't in any danger of withdrawing before the game, but warned tipsters and supporters alike that Pendlebury wouldn't be 100 per cent for the crucial clash.
"I'm not sure if they're cracked, but they're certainly sore," McClure explained on 3AW.
"He's going to play (but) he's keen for people to not know about it.
"Sorry, Scott."
Click PLAY below to hear Sam McClure explain more on 3AW
Date
March 31, 2016 - 7:12PM
Read later
inShare
submit to reddit
Scott Pendlebury will be crucial to Collingwood's chances.
Scott Pendlebury will be crucial to Collingwood's chances.
Collingwood captain Scott Pendlebury will carry sore ribs into Friday night's blockbuster against Richmond, says Sam 'Scoop' McClure.
The Sports Today newsbreaker said the Magpie superstar wasn't in any danger of withdrawing before the game, but warned tipsters and supporters alike that Pendlebury wouldn't be 100 per cent for the crucial clash.
"I'm not sure if they're cracked, but they're certainly sore," McClure explained on 3AW.
"He's going to play (but) he's keen for people to not know about it.
"Sorry, Scott."
Click PLAY below to hear Sam McClure explain more on 3AW
- Joined
- 14 May 2015
- Messages
- 2,048
- Likes
- 1,281
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
So Goldy or Gawn?
Goldy was only on 62 at 3QT last week, helped dramatically by his 4 contested marks in the final quarter when the game was in the balance. Stef Martin is no mug. I know Brissy bent over last week but are they really that bad?
Gawn started strong against Mummy and faded as the game went on. He scored 150 last time vs the bombers (McKernan), so this time they have a better ruck but a far worse team.
Is it splitting hairs or do ppl think there will be a clear winner?
Goldy was only on 62 at 3QT last week, helped dramatically by his 4 contested marks in the final quarter when the game was in the balance. Stef Martin is no mug. I know Brissy bent over last week but are they really that bad?
Gawn started strong against Mummy and faded as the game went on. He scored 150 last time vs the bombers (McKernan), so this time they have a better ruck but a far worse team.
Is it splitting hairs or do ppl think there will be a clear winner?
I think BomberSam's points above (post #108) is a valid answer to your query.
Personally, I would back a guy who has a much stronger history and has demonstrated that he can score well against his opponent on numerous occasion. After all, we did fork out $700k for the man so why not put him to good use. Gawn did match up against the Martin/Luey combo in round 16 of last year, scoring 105 off a 38HO and 13 disposals game (Melb won the match 60-36). For the records, Martin had 18HO and Luey had 26HO in that game.
Personally, I would back a guy who has a much stronger history and has demonstrated that he can score well against his opponent on numerous occasion. After all, we did fork out $700k for the man so why not put him to good use. Gawn did match up against the Martin/Luey combo in round 16 of last year, scoring 105 off a 38HO and 13 disposals game (Melb won the match 60-36). For the records, Martin had 18HO and Luey had 26HO in that game.
