Strategy Round 5: Trades

Are you trading Fyfe out?

  • Yes

    Votes: 14 25.5%
  • No

    Votes: 20 36.4%
  • Don’t own him

    Votes: 21 38.2%

  • Total voters
    55
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
21,651
Likes
26,150
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hahaha busted on Aisle 2. I just don’t think there is value to trading him in @ 410k now. Not when there are premiums only 100k (odd) away

What happens when and if he scores 2x 60’s b2b.. you’ll doubt him and be in a rush to trade him out again
Depends on personal circumstances I guess (I currently have Laird & Sicily in that price range) + Doc , happy to play the BE game with Hurn so :-

* back him in based on season data so far , could become a keeper
* could end up a viable D6/D7
* crashes and burns sideways trade to a fallen premium , probably 2 standouts depending on time frame

given $$$ are seemingly tight , worth the punt in my opinion
 
Joined
4 Feb 2013
Messages
268
Likes
46
AFL Club
Adelaide
Depends on personal circumstances I guess (I currently have Laird & Sicily in that price range) + Doc , happy to play the BE game with Hurn so :-

* back him in based on season data so far , could become a keeper
* could end up a viable D6/D7
* crashes and burns sideways trade to a fallen premium , probably 2 standouts depending on time frame

given $$$ are seemingly tight , worth the punt in my opinion
This + allows me the $ to go Taylor/Budarick to Whitfield next week
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
9,925
Likes
24,983
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Essendon- 2020:
Kicking efficiency of players to have played all 3 games and average more than 15 disposals:
1st- J Ridley= 88.6% (17D, 10.3 EK)
2nd- M Hurley= 75% (16D, 9EK)
3rd- Z Merrett= 71.9% (22.7D, 7.7 EK)
4th- A Saad= 71.1% (21.3D, 9EK)
5th- D Smith= 55.2% (16.7D, 5.3 EK)
6th- D Shiel= 52.3% (25.3D, 7.7 EK)
7th- K Langford= 51.7% (18D, 5EK)
8th- A McGrath= 45.2% (22D, 4.7 EK)

1593493727620.png
Key:
MP= Matches played
D= Disposals
EK= Effective Kicks
KE= Kicking Efficiency %
 
Joined
4 Mar 2015
Messages
610
Likes
141
AFL Club
Bulldogs
How is Xerri's JS and scoring? Considering him this week as it may help in a few weeks when I need to trade Pittonet out of R3.
 
Joined
6 Feb 2013
Messages
65
Likes
169
AFL Club
GWS Giants
How is Xerri's JS and scoring? Considering him this week as it may help in a few weeks when I need to trade Pittonet out of R3.
He replaced Mason Wood, who has surely had his last chance. That said, the Kangaroos have a quite a few tall options up forward and as a fringe 22 player, if he has a down week he may well lose his spot. I have had him at R3 since day 1, so I hope he stays in for a while, but not at all confident.
 
Joined
24 Jun 2013
Messages
261
Likes
484
AFL Club
West Coast
Howe > Daniel (at this stage)
Holding onto Fyfe. Undecided about the second trade (weighing up LButler, Serong, Williamson, Hill) Unsure about Butler’s long term JS
Serong & Hill & Williamson all priced awkwardly so uncertain whether blowing a trade / cash in a rookie and making 20-40k is even worth it
 
Joined
23 Jan 2014
Messages
299
Likes
775
Potentially Howe > Wingard & Ash > Serong leaves me with 342k for the next couple of weeks. Whitfield pretty certain for next week (for maybe Bewley or Fort) would complete my fwd line..
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
9,852
Likes
23,821
AFL Club
Carlton
Looking at Lachie Hunter in round 6, plenty of regret, trying to earn back respect of his teammates, has been working pretty hard. Won't get tagged, that goes to Macrae and Bont, expecting a high impact pending selection.
 
Joined
9 Feb 2014
Messages
459
Likes
244
AFL Club
North Melb.
Anyone have views on Mahony, how did he go in his first game? Is he worth it to bring in or should I look for another rookie?
Will hold his spot this week and I think that he should get 2 to 3 games in a row at a minimum.

Mahony, Hayden, Ahern and Hall are all in the team at the moment but I expect them to be in and out with players like Bonar, Scott, Murphy and Walker across the rest of the season
 
Joined
9 Feb 2014
Messages
459
Likes
244
AFL Club
North Melb.
How is Xerri's JS and scoring? Considering him this week as it may help in a few weeks when I need to trade Pittonet out of R3.
I think we were too tall on the weekend and I cant see how he can really play in the same team as Goldy. Would not be surprised to see him out this week and Wood back in (hopefully not) or even a possible debut for Hosie
 
Joined
2 Feb 2017
Messages
378
Likes
135
Option 1: Trade Fyfe
Howe > Ridley
Fyfe > Bont
200k in bank for Whitfield next week.

Option 2: Keep Fyfe
Howe > Hill
C.Taylor > Bont
15k in bank, hard to get Whitfield in next week.

Thoughts? Any feedback appreciated.
 
Top