Player X vs. Player Y

[Bomber18]

Mcdonald vs Webster vs Brayshaw vs Lloyd vs Savage? money doesn't matter by much

Lloyd outscores them all by 10ppg imo

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Mouch v Pendles v Dusty?

Definitely Pendles from that list

 

[Adrenaline]

Mcdonald vs Webster vs Brayshaw vs Lloyd vs Savage? money doesn't matter by much

if coin and trades dont matter, lloyd, webster, tmac, savage, and brayshaw

 

[Bomber18]

Definitely Pendles from that list

Just needed that confirmation. Pendles in and no more second thoughts!

 

[Ntay4]

Jelwood vs Duncan vs JPK vs Ward

 

[Prochard]

Jelwood vs Duncan vs JPK vs Ward

I only have Jelwood from that list and he's one of my biggest POD in an ownership sense. However, week in week out he does not fill me with confidence.

Mostly because his performance is so situational. It depends on so many other factors such as his disposal efficiency on the day (highly volatile), how much gametime Scott decides to give him (he gets more time on ground when game is close you'd think, otherwise Scott puts alot more time into Kelly) and whether he gets tagged (huge factor)

He seems like the # 1 tagged player this year at geelong despite the recruitment of Ablett, with tags very occasionally going to ablett/danger. He will probably get Hewett this week and probably could score 60-110. I will be having him on the bench with E on him, but would you really want to bring in someone who is only viable when you need to devote other resources to making him work?

JPK is the obvious choice here I think. Although I suspect S Selwood was brought in to step JPK this week... will probably receive more attention now after a purple patch.

Anyways, sorry for blabbering, out of the 4 I take JPK, but realistically I'm not looking at any of the 4 as my Fyfe replacement if I do decide to trade Fyfe.

 

[Ntay4]

I only have Jelwood from that list and he's one of my biggest POD in an ownership sense. However, week in week out he does not fill me with confidence.

Mostly because his performance is so situational. It depends on so many other factors such as his disposal efficiency on the day (highly volatile), how much gametime Scott decides to give him (he gets more time on ground when game is close you'd think, otherwise Scott puts alot more time into Kelly) and whether he gets tagged (huge factor)

He seems like the # 1 tagged player this year at geelong despite the recruitment of Ablett, with tags very occasionally going to ablett/danger. He will probably get Hewett this week and probably could score 60-110. I will be having him on the bench with E on him, but would you really want to bring in someone who is only viable when you need to devote other resources to making him work?

JPK is the obvious choice here I think. Although I suspect S Selwood was brought in to step JPK this week... will probably receive more attention now after a purple patch.

Anyways, sorry for blabbering, out of the 4 I take JPK, but realistically I'm not looking at any of the 4 as my Fyfe replacement if I do decide to trade Fyfe.

Cheers for the reply mate. After reading that I definitely do not want Jelwood ??. Will probs go with JPK - durable and proven

 

[NT.Thunder]

I only have Jelwood from that list and he's one of my biggest POD in an ownership sense. However, week in week out he does not fill me with confidence.

Mostly because his performance is so situational. It depends on so many other factors such as his disposal efficiency on the day (highly volatile), how much gametime Scott decides to give him (he gets more time on ground when game is close you'd think, otherwise Scott puts alot more time into Kelly) and whether he gets tagged (huge factor)

He seems like the # 1 tagged player this year at geelong despite the recruitment of Ablett, with tags very occasionally going to ablett/danger. He will probably get Hewett this week and probably could score 60-110. I will be having him on the bench with E on him, but would you really want to bring in someone who is only viable when you need to devote other resources to making him work?

JPK is the obvious choice here I think. Although I suspect S Selwood was brought in to step JPK this week... will probably receive more attention now after a purple patch.

Anyways, sorry for blabbering, out of the 4 I take JPK, but realistically I'm not looking at any of the 4 as my Fyfe replacement if I do decide to trade Fyfe.

I think last time Scooter went to Parker and Blicavs did a job on JPK - but not 100%

 

[Prochard]

I think last time Scooter went to Parker and Blicavs did a job on JPK - but not 100%

Yeah of course just a possible case, since i think most would agree JPK is sydney's #1 right now and not parker, also parker can go forward JPK sucks up forward

 

[BomberSam]

Neale vs. Clayton Oliver?

Fyfe replacement.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Neale vs. Clayton Oliver?

Fyfe replacement.

Clayton for mine, an uncharacteristic poor game from him on the weekend. Will be seething to put in a good one this week and should finish the year strong for mine.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Ed Curnow vs. Andrew Gaff vs. Lachie Neale vs. Dayne Beams ?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Ed Curnow vs. Andrew Gaff vs. Lachie Neale vs. Dayne Beams ?

Considering a few of those myself and I would rank them as:

Gaff > Neale > Curnow > Beams

Beams comes in last due to his durability. If you have 5 or more trades, he's worth a punt.

 

[Bermi]

Considering a few of those myself and I would rank them as:

Gaff > Neale > Curnow > Beams

Beams comes in last due to his durability. If you have 5 or more trades, he's worth a punt.

Where would you place M Crouch in that order?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Where would you place M Crouch in that order?

Someone posted that Crouch has been carrying a hand injury (or finger) but not sure what the real case is.
Assuming he is fully fit, he would be just behind Gaff and maybe on par with Neale.
My opinion of course.

 

[Saintellica]

Who to trade out?:
Petracca, Holman, Fritsch - to Wingard, McLean, Westhoff?
after trade if kept (Holman M9) or (Petracca F6 or F7 or M9) Fritsch (F6 or F7)

Fyfe replacement: Gaff, Selwood, Oliver?

thanks for any help - cheers

 

[Slacker]

Who to trade out?:
Petracca, Holman, Fritsch - to Wingard, McLean, Westhoff?
after trade if kept (Holman M9) or (Petracca F6 or F7 or M9) Fritsch (F6 or F7)

Fyfe replacement: Gaff, Selwood, Oliver?

thanks for any help - cheers

I'd reckon Petracca, Holman and Fritsch could all average about the same with Petracca arguably having some more potential for upside. Given Petracca is DPP which could also come in very handy, then imho trading out Holman would be the better option.

Gaff, Selwood, Oliver, mmm, I have concerns about all three so can't help you there sorry. Good Luck.

 

[quite ironic]

Kelly v Oliver?

 

[Zimmer]

Who to trade out?:
Petracca, Holman, Fritsch - to Wingard, McLean, Westhoff?
after trade if kept (Holman M9) or (Petracca F6 or F7 or M9) Fritsch (F6 or F7)

Fyfe replacement: Gaff, Selwood, Oliver?

thanks for any help - cheers

I traded Holman out last week. Sort of wish I'd kept him now.

 

[IDIG]

Ed Curnow vs. Andrew Gaff vs. Lachie Neale vs. Dayne Beams ?

I like Neale because of his ceiling then Gaff, Beams, Curnow.

Beams’ ability to go big makes him appealing but his inability to stay healthy makes him a no go for me.

Someone posted that Crouch has been carrying a hand injury (or finger) but not sure what the real case is.
Assuming he is fully fit, he would be just behind Gaff and maybe on par with Neale.
My opinion of course.

Yeah minor fracture they’re saying. I wonder if he gets a few ‘tests’ on the field like the good old days or is that frowned upon these days lol

Who to trade out?:
Petracca, Holman, Fritsch - to Wingard, McLean, Westhoff?
after trade if kept (Holman M9) or (Petracca F6 or F7 or M9) Fritsch (F6 or F7)

Fyfe replacement: Gaff, Selwood, Oliver?

thanks for any help - cheers

Probably trade Holman and I like Selwood or Oliver if those 3. Gun to head Oliver.

Kelly v Oliver?

Oliver for me but pretty hard to split. Kelly’s groin is a small concern.