Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Jurn Stern
- Start date
Current team is
Simo, Yeo, Laird, Hurn, Webster, Savage (Austin and Brander)
Mitchell, Kelly, Cripps, Neale, Danger, Oliver, Pendles, Coniglio (J.Smith, Spargo and Giro)
Gawn and Lycett (Olango)
Heeney, Sicily, McDonald, Smith, Hogan, JJK (Fritsch and Ahern)
2 trades now left. Have completed Fyfe - Neale. $105,300 in bank
Should i trade Lycett this week?
If so, is Sauce a good option?
Simo, Yeo, Laird, Hurn, Webster, Savage (Austin and Brander)
Mitchell, Kelly, Cripps, Neale, Danger, Oliver, Pendles, Coniglio (J.Smith, Spargo and Giro)
Gawn and Lycett (Olango)
Heeney, Sicily, McDonald, Smith, Hogan, JJK (Fritsch and Ahern)
2 trades now left. Have completed Fyfe - Neale. $105,300 in bank
Should i trade Lycett this week?
If so, is Sauce a good option?
All good options but I’d go Gaff ahead of the other 3.
Regarding your Shuey will make his way to $450k comment. Will you trade him if he doesn’t score well? You must be going well for trades if you’re in a position to do that
Regarding your Shuey will make his way to $450k comment. Will you trade him if he doesn’t score well? You must be going well for trades if you’re in a position to do that
Thanks everyone for your thoughts - Kelly it is for me, good to confirm.
As for the font, I'm not sure how or why it changed, although I was on my phone, for some reason the second paragraph seemed to go back to normal size, and even if I refreshed the page I couldn't avoid the small font.
Thanh, thanks for editing. As an FYI, it appears the system shows the message as being edited by a moderator, rather than you specifically. A non issue from my perspective, but just flagging it in case it is an unintended feature of the new system
As for the font, I'm not sure how or why it changed, although I was on my phone, for some reason the second paragraph seemed to go back to normal size, and even if I refreshed the page I couldn't avoid the small font.
Thanh, thanks for editing. As an FYI, it appears the system shows the message as being edited by a moderator, rather than you specifically. A non issue from my perspective, but just flagging it in case it is an unintended feature of the new system
Yeah Shuey falls into that gambley type pick you shouldn’t take but you kinda want to.
I’m one of the few that like him and if things were a little different I’d be taking a punt on him. Has a midfield friendly few weeks ahead of him so could average the higher end of his range, especially if he avoids the Jacobs tag.
I’m one of the few that like him and if things were a little different I’d be taking a punt on him. Has a midfield friendly few weeks ahead of him so could average the higher end of his range, especially if he avoids the Jacobs tag.
I essentially asked Kelly vs Neale in another thread (maybe the trades thread) so you may be able to get a good idea on that one there. I was erring on Kelly and that seemed to be the consensus. I think Neale is a good pick but Kelly a better one.
No real view on Gaff, sorry, except in that for me he was never part of the equation, even though I don't have him. I'm guessing a sore or rested NicNat probably doesn't help him though.
No real view on Gaff, sorry, except in that for me he was never part of the equation, even though I don't have him. I'm guessing a sore or rested NicNat probably doesn't help him though.
- Joined
- 21 Mar 2012
- Messages
- 4,202
- Likes
- 6,469
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Looking at offloading the underperforming Boak, Have 540k to spend.
Thinking Westhoff v Breust but think Hoff has hot/cold streaks and might be on the end of a hot one also don't want to go from one underperforming PA player to another, Breust seems a bit like chasing last weeks points.
Or any other player in this price range, Ranking has gone back to mid 20ks, only playing for pride so it doesn't matter if they are poddy or popular.
Thinking Westhoff v Breust but think Hoff has hot/cold streaks and might be on the end of a hot one also don't want to go from one underperforming PA player to another, Breust seems a bit like chasing last weeks points.
Or any other player in this price range, Ranking has gone back to mid 20ks, only playing for pride so it doesn't matter if they are poddy or popular.
Personally I don’t mind Westhoff and if I could get an M9/F7 swing player it would be him (my forwards already being full). With that said, I heard recently that Port have recently had quite a soft draw so that would be something to consider.
Depending on who you have, names that could get cheapish would include Heeney, McDonald, Buddy and maybe Gray. I have all of them (lucky me!), but that’s an indication that o see/saw them all as very top forwards.
I also saw Darling mentioned in the other thread and he’s a good one to watch, albeit I was skeptical that his scoring was sustainable. He will get cheaper though, so you’ll have a couple of games to watch him first if you’re looking to get him at his lowest price.
Depending on who you have, names that could get cheapish would include Heeney, McDonald, Buddy and maybe Gray. I have all of them (lucky me!), but that’s an indication that o see/saw them all as very top forwards.
I also saw Darling mentioned in the other thread and he’s a good one to watch, albeit I was skeptical that his scoring was sustainable. He will get cheaper though, so you’ll have a couple of games to watch him first if you’re looking to get him at his lowest price.
