Discussion 2019: Super Early Player & SC Game Change Discussion
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
- Status
Little confused here
Struggling to work out how the extension of the goal square and 6-6-6 starting positions helps with the "general congestion" around the game.
1. Yes a extra 9 metres for the guy kicking in gives him extra distance to kick , but if it is not a clean mark isn't it just moving the congestion a extra 9 metres ?
2. 6-6-6 is OK as it allows the 4 players in the square a little more time for a clearance before they are swamped so again if that get a clean kick into the F50 that will help but again solved nothing re general play.
So maybe , just maybe umpire the game properly , if a player is tackled and does not dispose of the ball by a kick or handball they are holding the ball and pay a free kick , quite simple really , dispose of the ball correctly.
Secondly this ruck nomination rule is farcical , throw it up/in and not wait , if 1 from each side contests well and good , if 2 from each side contest pay a free , again simple , it is not rocket science.
Struggling to work out how the extension of the goal square and 6-6-6 starting positions helps with the "general congestion" around the game.
1. Yes a extra 9 metres for the guy kicking in gives him extra distance to kick , but if it is not a clean mark isn't it just moving the congestion a extra 9 metres ?
2. 6-6-6 is OK as it allows the 4 players in the square a little more time for a clearance before they are swamped so again if that get a clean kick into the F50 that will help but again solved nothing re general play.
So maybe , just maybe umpire the game properly , if a player is tackled and does not dispose of the ball by a kick or handball they are holding the ball and pay a free kick , quite simple really , dispose of the ball correctly.
Secondly this ruck nomination rule is farcical , throw it up/in and not wait , if 1 from each side contests well and good , if 2 from each side contest pay a free , again simple , it is not rocket science.
I didn't touch any of Laird , Hibberd , Hurley or Yeo this season st their starting prices so unlikely to pay $ 580k next year.
Might very well come down to Doc's discount and how he is looking preseason to determine the makeup of defences.
Williams might be back soon so we can gauge his recovery.
Just have to wait for prices and positions to be released.
Might very well come down to Doc's discount and how he is looking preseason to determine the makeup of defences.
Williams might be back soon so we can gauge his recovery.
Just have to wait for prices and positions to be released.
If he’s a defender, he’s right at the top of the list for me.
I’m not sure how realistic it is but I’d probably start 2 of Lloyd/Laird/Whitfield and either Doc/Williams depending on discount. Then a Brayshaw/Witherden type.
I almost hoping Brayshaw doesn’t have defender status looking at it now!
Haha yeah. I wasn’t sure how he started the year and whether he’d spent enough time in the backline to qualify for DPP. Assuming they take the whole year’s games into consider when deciding positions.
Agreed. He had that slowish start which makes him a little under priced. Also room for improvement efficiency wise (I’m assuming from his DT:SC ratio) and plenty of natural improvement which will come when he gets some continuity in his play.
What I like most about him is his ability to find the footy and to rack up massive numbers, which makes him fantasy gold.
I’m not sure how realistic it is but I’d probably start 2 of Lloyd/Laird/Whitfield and either Doc/Williams depending on discount. Then a Brayshaw/Witherden type.
I almost hoping Brayshaw doesn’t have defender status looking at it now!
Haha yeah. I wasn’t sure how he started the year and whether he’d spent enough time in the backline to qualify for DPP. Assuming they take the whole year’s games into consider when deciding positions.
Agreed. He had that slowish start which makes him a little under priced. Also room for improvement efficiency wise (I’m assuming from his DT:SC ratio) and plenty of natural improvement which will come when he gets some continuity in his play.
What I like most about him is his ability to find the footy and to rack up massive numbers, which makes him fantasy gold.
- Status