Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[XabiFernando]

Witherden + $60k v Dunkley

 

[teatai]

Dunkley (F4) + BCrouch (M5) + Collins (D4) + 15k.

vs

Moore + Sloane + Hanley + 76k.

option 1

also I would still try and facilitate cash to try and get Moore somehow I feel his a bargain if he avgs 75+

 

[teatai]

Witherden + $60k v Dunkley

where would Witherden be position? And also Dunkley?
I would go Dunkley, I haven’t seen much upside to Witherdens game during the JLT but that’s my opinion could be wrong could kill it in the season

 

[XabiFernando]

Witherden currently my D2, Dunkley would be F3.

Would swing Moore to D to preserve structure.

 

[teatai]

Witherden currently my D2, Dunkley would be F3.

Would swing Moore to D to preserve structure.

I’ll still go with Dunkley in that situation, this year seems to be the year where you can go slightly weak in the back line whilst you’d need to go heavy in the fwds

 

[jaca]

Lobb vs Lycett : P

 

[teatai]

Lobb vs Lycett : P

Not a fan of either, also haven’t research Lobb too much but in your case I would go Lycett as from memory he can ton up at times when his solo rucking but also when he has another ruckman to contend with you get the odd 60-80 scores

 

[Johnsy44]

Milera and 100k vs Crisp vs Gray vs Dunkley vs Darling vs Greene and 186k

Unsure if I would do anything with the cash. Could go Goldy to Grundy or a rookie up to Liba leaving 3k

 

[Hondo]

Would appreciate thoughts??
Macrae + Darling (F3) + Greene (F4)
vs
Oliver (M2) + Dunkly (F3) + Worpel (F4)

Option 1

 

[Hondo]

Milera and 100k vs Crisp vs Gray vs Dunkley vs Darling vs Greene and 186k

Unsure if I would do anything with the cash. Could go Goldy to Grundy or a rookie up to Liba leaving 3k

So the x v y is

Milera/Goldy v Greene/Grundy?

 

[Johnsy44]

So the x v y is

Milera/Goldy v Greene/Grundy?

Depending on how I utilised my money yes. Have Moore in my team which allows me to get either a Def or Fwd. still not sure what I am even doing in the rucks which changes my structure. I even considering going Goldy to Lycett. Really want to get Rocky back in

 

[Leroy]

Would appreciate thoughts??
Macrae + Darling (F3) + Greene (F4)
vs
Oliver (M2) + Dunkly (F3) + Worpel (F4)

My personal stance is that Greene is a non-starter. He is being eased into the season and I can't see him thrashing out 100s until he gets fit... and there's every chance he gets suspended in the mean time
If he starts tearing it up I'll bring him in, but can't see his price rocketing out of reach and the risk looks big.

So B.

... but with Jack Higgins

 

[Johnsy44]

Darling vs Walters

 

[Bontempele]

Milera and 100k vs Crisp vs Gray vs Dunkley vs Darling vs Greene and 186k

Unsure if I would do anything with the cash. Could go Goldy to Grundy or a rookie up to Liba leaving 3k

Dunkley I reckon. Most likely of those players to go 100+, and don't think Greene is reliable enough.

 

[TommyGobbler]

Darling vs Walters

Darling. Take out the 2 injury affected scores last year and Darling was a Top 6 Forward. Walters too injury prone.

 

[TommyGobbler]

Brodie Smith & Dom Sheed
VS.
Lachie Whitfield & Zak Butters

 

[Johnsy44]

Goldy and Collins

Vs

English and Milera

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Darling vs Walters

Darling for mine.

 

[NT.Thunder]

Neale vs Dusty

Kelly vs Dunkley

 

[XabiFernando]

Brodie Smith & Dom Sheed
VS.
Lachie Whitfield & Zak Butters

Great one!

First combo averages more (say 180 v 150 - but I'm bearish on Butters) but the likelihood of using 2 trades in getting to full premo is higher with option 1. Option 2 looks like a 1 trade proposition with whitfield holding.

Consider the risk in context of your overall team (are you filled with injury riddled mid pricers or your safe Neale types?).