Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[teatai]

Goldy + Worpel (F4) + 114k ( for corrective trades or even upgrade M Crouch)
Vs
Gawn + Greene (F4) + 11k

 

[Johnsy44]

Ridley vs LDU/Hatley/Scott/Smith

Having a Mid rookie allows me to move Drew on field in the fwd instead of mids, Move Moore to defence giving a swing set and Gives some extra cash

 

[Zimmer]

Goldy + Worpel (F4) + 114k ( for corrective trades or even upgrade M Crouch)
Vs
Gawn + Greene (F4) + 11k

That's a tough one, but I reckon Greene is the biggest risk. Is there an alternative that allows you Gawn?

 

[Zimmer]

Laird and Oliver + 15k
v
Macrae and Whitfield + 150 k other possible upgrades/corrections
also

Scrimshaw v Ridley

(Is it clear that I'm getting to that nutty stage?)

 

[Hasnoshoes]

Billings (F5) & Collins (D5) vs Whitfield (D2) & Balta/Petru/Parker (Bench)

 

[Hasnoshoes]

Ridley vs LDU/Hatley/Scott/Smith

Having a Mid rookie allows me to move Drew on field in the fwd instead of mids, Move Moore to defence giving a swing set and Gives some extra cash

I'd just take Scott mate. Seems as good JS as any of the others, decent scoring potential and basement price.

 

[teatai]

That's a tough one, but I reckon Greene is the biggest risk. Is there an alternative that allows you Gawn?

Collins my (D4) down to burgess means I field
Scrimshaw Clark Durrsma (Burgess Hore) ?

 

[Johnsy44]

Moore vs Ridley

 

[teatai]

Laird and Oliver + 15k
v
Macrae and Whitfield + 150 k other possible upgrades/corrections
also

Scrimshaw v Ridley

(Is it clear that I'm getting to that nutty stage?)

I like Macrae and Whitfield + 150k

As for Scrimshaw v Ridley kinda depends on team line ups both can score well Ridley maybe a bit better but not far off, at this stage Scrimshaw and save the cash

 

[Adrenaline]

Dusty v M Crouch

i would say mcrouch
i asked a similar question this morning and most people said m crouch due to its a safer option. matt might not get the massive scores like dusty but he will get you 105-115 each week

 

[Adrenaline]

Moore vs Ridley

moore for me. he also gives you the dpp flexibility

 

[Connoisseur]

Andrews, Oliver, Dunkley of the first lot quite comfortably for me. I like betting against Whitfield early.

Moore, Scrimshaw & Darling of the second group, Greene at F3 could spell disaster early.

Thanks @BigRuss.

With the news regarding J Kelly I don't think I can risk starting him anymore due to the fact that if he's a late withdrawal options are very limited. Therefore which combination for replacing J Kelly do you prefer.

1. Out: B Grundy, J Kelly, In: M Gawn, C Oliver
2. Out: J Kelly, L Whitfield, J Darling, In: C Oliver, H Andrews, J Dunkley/D Mundy
3. Out: J Kelly, J Darling, In: P Cripps, J Billings
4. Out: J Scrimshaw, J Kelly, In: X Duursma, C Oliver

 

[Adrenaline]

With Wilkie being named down back as a bench option I've ended up with this x v y:

Brad Crouch + Brodie Smith
vs
Oliver + Wilkie

After switching to the second one I feel a LOT happier with my team. Anyone want to argue for option A?

oli and rookie. brad crouch can break down after 2 rounds. he is a high risk player for me.

 

[Adrenaline]

laird vs whitfield vs lloyd? sorry if this has been mentioned

 

[BigRuss]

Thanks @BigRuss.

With the news regarding J Kelly I don't think I can risk starting him anymore due to the fact that if he's a late withdrawal options are very limited. Therefore which combination for replacing J Kelly do you prefer.

1. Out: B Grundy, J Kelly, In: M Gawn, C Oliver
2. Out: J Kelly, L Whitfield, J Darling, In: C Oliver, H Andrews, J Dunkley/D Mundy
3. Out: J Kelly, J Darling, In: P Cripps, J Billings
4. Out: J Scrimshaw, J Kelly, In: X Duursma, C Oliver

Thats a bloody hard one mate. I dont like Andrews or Billings, so rule out 2 and 3, though if you could replace Andrews with a Hurn/Crisp type Id probably go that one.

Outside of that I think option 4, Duursma and Scrimshaw seem about the same to me, as do Kelly and Oliver, the closest to a like for like swap imo.

 

[quite ironic]

Coniglio, Scrimshaw, Bewley
Vs
Oliver, Duursma, Gibbons

M2, D6, M11 for spots.

 

[Connoisseur]

Thats a bloody hard one mate. I dont like Andrews or Billings, so rule out 2 and 3, though if you could replace Andrews with a Hurn/Crisp type Id probably go that one.

Outside of that I think option 4, Duursma and Scrimshaw seem about the same to me, as do Kelly and Oliver, the closest to a like for like swap imo.

Thanks. Hopefully Scrimshaw is not named which will make the decision a whole lot easier. Really only between Option 2 and 4 as I don't want to forego B Grundy and I don't think Billings will reach a 90-95+ avg. Really like Andrews and would love to give him another go in my side as he only lasted 1/2 a quarter last year but that would involve foregoing Whitfield which I'm hesitant on.

 

[WindyHillWizard]

Thanks @BigRuss.

With the news regarding J Kelly I don't think I can risk starting him anymore due to the fact that if he's a late withdrawal options are very limited. Therefore which combination for replacing J Kelly do you prefer.

1. Out: B Grundy, J Kelly, In: M Gawn, C Oliver
2. Out: J Kelly, L Whitfield, J Darling, In: C Oliver, H Andrews, J Dunkley/D Mundy
3. Out: J Kelly, J Darling, In: P Cripps, J Billings
4. Out: J Scrimshaw, J Kelly, In: X Duursma, C Oliver

I like option 4. Minimal changes and allows you to keep the big dogs. Reckon Duursma may be a better pick anyway.

 

[Zimmer]

Goldy + Worpel (F4) + 114k ( for corrective trades or even upgrade M Crouch)
Vs
Gawn + Greene (F4) + 11k

Go Goldy and Worpel then use the cash. I imagine Grundy is your other Ruck.

 

[DojoWarrior]

Thanks @BigRuss.

With the news regarding J Kelly I don't think I can risk starting him anymore due to the fact that if he's a late withdrawal options are very limited. Therefore which combination for replacing J Kelly do you prefer.

1. Out: B Grundy, J Kelly, In: M Gawn, C Oliver
2. Out: J Kelly, L Whitfield, J Darling, In: C Oliver, H Andrews, J Dunkley/D Mundy
3. Out: J Kelly, J Darling, In: P Cripps, J Billings
4. Out: J Scrimshaw, J Kelly, In: X Duursma, C Oliver

I'd go 4 personally! I would avoid making other big changes to my team just to replace him, almost straight swap for Clarry.