Discussion Round 4: Teams & In Game Discussion

Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,764
Likes
11,765
AFL Club
West Coast
Absolutely the worst... You gonna hold now or gone next week?!
Much to my despair I will probably hold. I am trying to use logic to convince myself of this decision however SC and logic seem to be further and further apart these days. Hoff rarely misses a game so I am thinking he has 18 games left. If he was going to ave 90 from the start of the season (I clearly hoped for more plus ruck coverage) then he would score 1980 points. So far he has scored 248 leaving 1699 from 18 games to get to season 90 ave. To do that he will ave 94 from here. Also Dixon will be back soon and I am sure that will change the set up. Do I sound convincing?
 
Joined
22 Feb 2013
Messages
9,668
Likes
20,502
AFL Club
Hawthorn
1563/17 - Danger C. Managed to dodge Grundy VC.

Yesterday was ****e. Ruined my weekend.

I have made one trade this season (Mundy to TKelly rd 3), so far I'm -109 points. Going well.

SC can go f itself. I'm working in the garden today with the radio and no phone. You may hear a scream and my head explode if the Hawks lose...
 

psykro

100 Games Club
Joined
25 Apr 2013
Messages
889
Likes
571
AFL Club
Richmond
pretty bad round, but i have a lot of bad luck in this game. years gone by i have had multiple games where im projected 2300+ and scored 1850, so by comparison this ain't so bad : ]

but geez this game can sting in the way things work out. i have tried to be sensible and stay off injury-proners like rocky and libba, not chase their points expecting a revert to mean like boak... the only "aggressive" trade i made was also based on what seemed sound reasoning [heeney to tkelly] that ankles don't get better without rest... these 'sensible" decisions have cost me about 500 points minimum lol. so far :ROFLMAO:

on the plus side, kept b smith based on seedsman injury. so it's not all angsty. sometimes logic works. over to you cousins, you came into my team for libba so i could roll with grawndy combo, make me proud! [and less depressed lol]
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,413
Likes
65,513
AFL Club
Collingwood
Much to my despair I will probably hold. I am trying to use logic to convince myself of this decision however SC and logic seem to be further and further apart these days. Hoff rarely misses a game so I am thinking he has 18 games left. If he was going to ave 90 from the start of the season (I clearly hoped for more plus ruck coverage) then he would score 1980 points. So far he has scored 248 leaving 1699 from 18 games to get to season 90 ave. To do that he will ave 94 from here. Also Dixon will be back soon and I am sure that will change the set up. Do I sound convincing?
Have you heard anything concrete re Dixon?

He’s listed as ‘indefinite’ on the AFL injury list, and I think was listed as something else (but not overly promising) like ‘TBC’ over recent weeks.
 
Joined
9 Mar 2012
Messages
10,810
Likes
16,193
AFL Club
Adelaide
17/1613, Neale (C) ok I guess, but don’t have popular choices Lloyd, Heeney or Grundy so can’t see a ranking jump this week with only one premo (Cripps) to come. Will be battling to hit 2000.
 
Joined
9 Mar 2012
Messages
10,810
Likes
16,193
AFL Club
Adelaide
Fyfe out, looped Atkins then couldn't see scores when playing football and took Butters! Looking 2000-2100, at least last minute followed the masses and put VC on Grundy when I head Bucks was saying there was upside to his HTA. Alternative was Danger - yuk.

So the Sheed and BCrouch experiments looking like they may need to be traded sometime. Rocky? Still ok value, should we be bringing him in by round 6 when his poor score rolls off? Williams and Brodie Smith look like they need to be traded also, will let them have a good run against easy teams. Hopefully some decent rooks like Jack Ross can keep it up.

Dunkley's role keep changing, think CBA was down this week significantly. Has Carlton,Dockers, Richmond, Lions, Cats and North and Eagles pre the byes.
Jury’s still out on Brodie Smith, scores 104 last night so has scored 2/4 def keeper scores so far, but you might be right about Brad Crouch. Still I’ll probably hold him for around another week, should still make a little bit of cash.
 

THCLT

BBL|05 Winner
Joined
13 Sep 2014
Messages
18,597
Likes
118,268
AFL Club
North Melb.
16/1,447

Scrimshaw
Cripps (c), Cousins, Walsh
Newnes, Setterfield

Missed the Grundy (vc), Danger had one of his worst efforts after QT I can remember, so now will be resting on the broad shoulders in Cripps. Not only will he have the Blues to carry but also the fate of my team fortunes for this round. In the spirit that is Easter, this round has been the round to break your 'duck' egg. Just like Melbourne & North Melbourne, the Blues will hopefully break theirs with Cripps playing a starring role!
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,413
Likes
65,513
AFL Club
Collingwood
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
How do you delete a reply before you post it if you have replied to wrong person or changed your mind that you actually want to post it?
 
Joined
22 Oct 2014
Messages
7,882
Likes
41,731
AFL Club
North Melb.
pretty bad round, but i have a lot of bad luck in this game. years gone by i have had multiple games where im projected 2300+ and scored 1850, so by comparison this ain't so bad : ]

but geez this game can sting in the way things work out. i have tried to be sensible and stay off injury-proners like rocky and libba, not chase their points expecting a revert to mean like boak... the only "aggressive" trade i made was also based on what seemed sound reasoning [heeney to tkelly] that ankles don't get better without rest... these 'sensible" decisions have cost me about 500 points minimum lol. so far :ROFLMAO:

on the plus side, kept b smith based on seedsman injury. so it's not all angsty. sometimes logic works. over to you cousins, you came into my team for libba so i could roll with grawndy combo, make me proud! [and less depressed lol]
I went the other way and actually traded in Libba and Rocky this week (for Fyfe and Scott) but it was against my better judgement and I feel dirty havng done it.

Interesting that 150 points extra it got me this week has a strangely cleansing effect. However I am not convinced it will work out well in the long run.
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,413
Likes
65,513
AFL Club
Collingwood
Jury’s still out on Brodie Smith, scores 104 last night so has scored 2/4 def keeper scores so far, but you might be right about Brad Crouch. Still I’ll probably hold him for around another week, should still make a little bit of cash.
Do you think Seedsman being out helps Brodie?

I hadn’t viewed him as a likely keeper, so if he happy if he just had a few better scores and could be cashed out for a nice price pre byes.
 
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
in my opinion players like De Boer are a blight on the game. The AFL would do much better to stamp out this behaviour out of the game, rather than continually add quixotic rules.
I tend to agree with you apart from the quixotic part (I'll have to google that one). The elite who is being tagged by an amateur should be allowed some leeway to dispose of them and make them think twice about their tagging duties.
 
Top