Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[PC]

Simpkin v Bailey Smith?

 

[Ironhawk]

Simpkin v Bailey Smith?

I rate both. Picked both in my Lock and Load team.

Simpkin a little ahead based on form to date, but I would be happy with either.

 

[aleceee]

I rate both. Picked both in my Lock and Load team.

Simpkin a little ahead based on form to date, but I would be happy with either.

Where would you rank Petracca compared to both of these?

 

[Ironhawk]

Where would you rank Petracca compared to both of these?

I traded Petracca in before Rd 2, no regrets. I would still pick him again. Will be close to Simpkin, I would rate Petracca just ahead.

 

[BomberSam]

Williamson vs. Rivers?

Bazlenka vs. Simpkin vs. Petracca this week? Will probably end up with all 3.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Williamson vs. Rivers?

Bazlenka vs. Simpkin vs. Petracca this week? Will probably end up with all 3.

Rivers

This week, probably Simpkin. Like all 3 though.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Who's Bazlenka?
Bailey Smith?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Who's Bazlenka?
Bailey Smith?

Correct

 

[Ironhawk]

Williamson vs. Rivers?

Bazlenka vs. Simpkin vs. Petracca this week? Will probably end up with all 3.

Rivers
Petracca

Refer the last 10 or so posts before yours for my thoughts on most of those mentioned. Rivers showed a bit in R2 and expect he'll do better in that head to head.

 

[bloke]

This is probably a bit speculative given exposed form, but how would you rank Williamson, Geogiades (if named) and L Butler as trade ins this week?

I'm thinking 1. Georgiades 2. Williamson 3. Butler but I've not seen much of any of them

 

[Ironhawk]

This is probably a bit speculative given exposed form, but how would you rank Williamson, Geogiades (if named) and L Butler as trade ins this week?

I'm thinking 1. Georgiades 2. Williamson 3. Butler but I've not seen much of any of them

I am in a similar spot to you, haven't seen much of any of them and that ranking seems about right to me. I don't expect much from any of the three, Georgiades is the only one I would be considering at all based on his first score.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

This is probably a bit speculative given exposed form, but how would you rank Williamson, Geogiades (if named) and L Butler as trade ins this week?

I'm thinking 1. Georgiades 2. Williamson 3. Butler but I've not seen much of any of them

Throw in KPP from Melbourne and we've got a real rookie conundrum on our hands.
How you rank them looks correct to me with KPP perhaps in between Georg & Williamson

 

[Toothless Tigers]

Considering Simpkin and Petrecca are roughly equal who is better value and who do you bring in first?



Thank you for taking time to reply

 

[Ironhawk]

Considering Simpkin and Petrecca are roughly equal who is better value and who do you bring in first?



Thank you for taking time to reply

I chose Petracca first, I bought him in before R2, Simpkin this rd. Would have preferred the opposite.

Both are sitting on about 80% CBA, both have very good rucks hitting to them, fairly similar stats. North have probably had the slightly easier draw which may account for Simpkin's better scoring so far.

Simpkin maybe, based on one extra game of data and the better overall scores. Either will hopefully be a good pick.

 

[Inside50]

Considering Simpkin and Petrecca are roughly equal who is better value and who do you bring in first?



Thank you for taking time to reply

Too hard to say, just get both

 

[Slammer]

Ridley vs Doedee

 

[Bontempele]

Ridley vs Doedee

Hamill and bank the cash for an upgrade

 

[Ironhawk]

Ridley vs Doedee

Got burned by Ridley last year so I am biased and prefer Doedee.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Fyfe vs Neale

Fyfe has Suns, Crows, Melb and Eagles

Neale has Crows, Port, Pies, Swans.

Took Miller was asked twice this week if he was going to Fyfe on AFL360 and ignored the question. Haven't seen GC tag yet. Crows a little bit Q4, Port no but think Ebert use to do the role, Swans have Hewett who went to the wrong guy last night. Hutching 4-5 weeks away.

No Gawn in the side. Fyfe may allow me to bring in a fwd premium if I don't bring Serong in next week.

 

[Herbie66]

Fyfe vs Neale

Fyfe has Suns, Crows, Melb and Eagles

Neale has Crows, Port, Pies, Swans.

Took Miller was asked twice this week if he was going to Fyfe on AFL360 and ignored the question. Haven't seen GC tag yet. Crows a little bit Q4, Port no but think Ebert use to do the role, Swans have Hewett who went to the wrong guy last night. Hutching 4-5 weeks away.

No Gawn in the side. Fyfe may allow me to bring in a fwd premium if I don't bring Serong in next week.

Tuk Tuk was definitely following Sloane the first half last week.