Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
192
Likes
470
AFL Club
Richmond
Fyfe Vs Simpkin & Bont?
Bringing in either Fyfe or Simpkin this week. Simpkin this week will allow me to snag Bont also next week after downgrading Naismith. That's probably the smart route but no Fyfe scares me with his draw to come
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
2,767
Likes
8,697
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Fyfe Vs Simpkin & Bont?
Bringing in either Fyfe or Simpkin this week. Simpkin this week will allow me to snag Bont also next week after downgrading Naismith. That's probably the smart route but no Fyfe scares me with his draw to come
Connoisseur just traded in Simpkin, sounds like you should go for Fyfe. ;)

Seriously though, who would you get instead of Bont next week if you bring in Fyfe this week? I am leaning to Simpkin + Bont, but you may be able to get a decent mid to go with Fyfe for that to work better.
 
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
192
Likes
470
AFL Club
Richmond
Connoisseur just traded in Simpkin, sounds like you should go for Fyfe. ;)

Seriously though, who would you get instead of Bont next week if you bring in Fyfe this week? I am leaning to Simpkin + Bont, but you may be able to get a decent mid to go with Fyfe for that to work better.
Haha Simpkin will be back under $400k in a couple weeks in that case
If I go Fyfe path will likely just bring in 2 rookies next week
 
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
192
Likes
470
AFL Club
Richmond
I would go for Simpkin then. Fingers crossed.
Thanks mate. Couldn't control myself... Went Fyfe against all advice and conventional wisdom... Seems to be the season for it haha. Think it's more fun having him in than backing against him this year. At least I can only blame myself if it backfires.
Should be able to grab Yeo in a couple weeks anyway
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
2,767
Likes
8,697
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Danger vs Bont vs Duncan
Looking at BE's and averages: Danger BE 108 AV 100, Bont BE 69 AV 108, Duncan BE 99 AV 119. From that, Bont possibly has the best short term growth. All played well last round. Duncan has probably been the most consistent this season, but who knows. All seem reasonable selections. I'll say Bont if I had to pick one I guess, he did look good this round (I didn't watch much of the Geelong match).

I would honestly take Ridley, go the form player. Laird is not in form.
 
Top