Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Darkie]

Take Aarts 75 and bench 1 of D.Smith, steven, Rankine ???
Or just roll with the cover for a late out 🤔

Same choice for me with Geo, Rankine, Taylor vs Crows and Hill if fit. I went with the cover.

 

[Steuby]

Hurn v Stewart v Laird?

 

[Crabby Skills]

Hurn v Stewart v Laird?

I like Stewy. I'll be getting him in next week. Skipping Hurn.

 

[Steuby]

I like Stewy. I'll be getting him in next week. Skipping Hurn.

Skipping Hurn altogether or because his bye is next round?

 

[Ironhawk]

Hurn v Stewart v Laird?

Not Laird. He has been too poor this year to be a keeper target now, do you want a 90 average player?

Hurn seems to have turned the corner and will play a lot of games in Perth, where he is scoring better. Seems to have some upside.

Stewart will be a good buy, but wait a week. 162 BE.

If it's this week, I would say Hurn, even with his bye next round - all 3 will have a bye at some point. If it's next round, I prefer Stewart.

 

[JoeyRulz]

Ling vs Watson.

 

[Ironhawk]

Ling vs Watson.

I haven't seen them in state leagues, juniors etc, so there's likely others who can make a better call on this one.

Neither look like great scorers based on 1 game, I'm going to say Watson, but I will point out my record with rookies is pretty awful.

 

[Imcjb]

Whitfield vs Gaff ???

 

[Ironhawk]

Whitfield vs Gaff ???

Whitfield, being forward eligible gives the extra flexibility. Close otherwise.

 

[Deeman1]

64 v Noble on field instead?

 

[Ironhawk]

64 v Noble on field instead?

From Noble's 6 games this season he has two scores in the 70's, third best score is 64. Seems he is 50/50 to get that much, and if he does, not by much. Take the 64.

 

[The Myth]

Gresham + Cripps vs Wingard + Duncan

 

[Ironhawk]

Gresham + Cripps vs Wingard + Duncan

Fairly even to me. Both options have 1 player with a bye this round, which you would have to cop. I probably slightly prefer option 1 overall, but either looks good.

 

[The Myth]

Fairly even to me. Both options have 1 player with a bye this round, which you would have to cop. I probably slightly prefer option 1 overall, but either looks good.

I would be bringing the player on the bye in next round, and the other this week.

Maybe the fixture release expected today will help my conundrum.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Mitch Duncan ($521,500)

vs.

Patrick Dangerfield ($590,000)

 

[PC]

Mitch Duncan ($521,500)

vs.

Patrick Dangerfield ($590,000)

Duncan for me.

 

[Ironhawk]

Mitch Duncan ($521,500)

vs.

Patrick Dangerfield ($590,000)

Duncan is averaging more even with his injury game included and is $70K cheaper. Duncan for me too.

 

[BomberSam]

Mitch Duncan ($521,500)

vs.

Patrick Dangerfield ($590,000)

As a Danger owner and a new Duncan owner, I would 100% take Duncan first.

 

[BomberSam]

Yeo vs. Viney going forward?

 

[Ironhawk]

Yeo vs. Viney going forward?

Viney for me. Bit disappointed I traded him out after R5, 3 very good scores since before a down game (most Dees had a bad game last week). Yeo could outscore him, but hasn't shown enough for me to be convinced to date.