Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
Might depend on who you already have. Say you don’t have B Smith (cheap) or Greenwood (getting cheap and playing pure mid seemingly, note drop in tackle count) or Trac (#1 forward? Durable with game in hand) then I can see the merit in getting Duncan and leaving room for one of those names up forward. The reverse is also true, but other than Titch and Cripps (and Duncan himself) I’m not sure that there are standout trade in mid options.
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Hawks is right on those points. Hill can be 50-80 whereas Buda is more 50.
The other factor is Hill is def which is hard to have rookies there and do you have a dpp mid/fwd. I have plenty of the later, however, I moved Hill on last week as I brought in McKay who I felt was a safe def rookie.
If going down to a dodge defender then would keep Hill, whereas a dodge mid or fwd is less of a risk.
The other factor is Hill is def which is hard to have rookies there and do you have a dpp mid/fwd. I have plenty of the later, however, I moved Hill on last week as I brought in McKay who I felt was a safe def rookie.
If going down to a dodge defender then would keep Hill, whereas a dodge mid or fwd is less of a risk.
Thanks @GrainFedBeef and @Ironhawk - you make some good points.
In a close one I ended up keeping Hill, largely given the uniqueness of his DPP and def eligibility. In my side Buda largely seems to replicate Close so I feel like Hill adds some balance ... now just hoping he can get on the park for the most part!
Hill also allows me to lock in Aarts’ 87 which helped nudge me over the line.
In a close one I ended up keeping Hill, largely given the uniqueness of his DPP and def eligibility. In my side Buda largely seems to replicate Close so I feel like Hill adds some balance ... now just hoping he can get on the park for the most part!
Hill also allows me to lock in Aarts’ 87 which helped nudge me over the line.
Take your pick I say. Hawthorn play Freo, West Coast play Carlton, then they play each other in Rd 12. I don't see either being affected more than the other. BE for Shuey 45 v Titch 72. Titch averaging more though.
If forced to choose, I would get Titch first, possibly a bit less competition for points in the Hawthorn midfield.
If forced to choose, I would get Titch first, possibly a bit less competition for points in the Hawthorn midfield.
Yeah, that's why I'm gambling.
I did compile a quick chart of OMac's CBA versus SC Scoring
The idea is to get him sub $400k for hopefully a 90+ average; the alternative would be to wait for Greenwood down the line who might get to $500k and with cash gen so hard I figured I might as well take the risk and finish my forward line.
I did compile a quick chart of OMac's CBA versus SC Scoring
The idea is to get him sub $400k for hopefully a 90+ average; the alternative would be to wait for Greenwood down the line who might get to $500k and with cash gen so hard I figured I might as well take the risk and finish my forward line.