Strategy Round 3: Trades

For those that own him, what are you doing with Cripps?

  • Trade

    Votes: 63 51.6%
  • Keep

    Votes: 59 48.4%

  • Total voters
    122
Joined
13 Mar 2021
Messages
13
Likes
35
AFL Club
St Kilda
Not sure whether I’m touching Neale or just holding him.
I will likely go with
Cripps>Dunkley
Caldwell>Tex

Don’t like getting rid of Cripps but he’s underperforming and looks slow. Helps me bring in Dunkley without really losing any money and bringing in a keeper.

If I trade Neale I would keep Cripps and go for someone like Clarry.

Thoughts?
 
Joined
24 Jun 2013
Messages
1,379
Likes
4,687
AFL Club
West Coast
Tex v GCS then NM, Freo the weeks after

If he hits his projected of 98 this week +98k

Does anyone know what he would go up to if he scored another 2x 98’s (or just 100 for that matter?)

$500k?
 
Joined
13 Mar 2021
Messages
13
Likes
35
AFL Club
St Kilda
thinking....

caldwell + sharp -> cumming + warner

leaving out flynn
not sure whether its worth
If your midfield rookies are strong I would really consider getting Flynn. His cash generation is going to be probably top 5 for the rookies. He will be main rucking for GWS until the later rounds at the earliest.
 
Joined
18 Sep 2012
Messages
225
Likes
845
AFL Club
Adelaide
Anyone looking to chase Tex’s massive break even this week? He is really going to tempt me this week, I know it.
I want to however I'm really hesitant to trade in my favourite player as I don't want to get extra ****ty when our forward line delivery sucks and he can't get into the game.

Pros to Tex:

- Fixture.

GC, North, Freo, Hawthorn, GWS are our next 5 games. We should be relatively competitive in all of those which should at least give our forward line a little bit of supply, whether it's good is the big question.

GC I imagine he'll likely get Collins who is pretty decent, held Kennedy to 2.2 and nothing to gain by looking at his match up v North.

North are without Tarrant which has to help, no idea who is playing in his stead as I only really plan to watch North once this year (unless we play them twice).

Freo have been pretty undersized down back for a while now. McDonald was made to look like a star in round 1 against Hamling who went out, not sure who is next in line after him.

Hawks will have the Frost match I imagine. His speed might be alright against Tex on the lead however Riewoldt managed to kick 4 on him on the weekend. Held Wright to a goal but Wright is pretty unproven.

GWS should be a Davis matchup which will probably be pretty tough but with how GWS are playing, maybe we're a chance to be competitive against them.

- Form. With him rolling the way he is, we're looking to kick it to him a lot and Frampton is a bit of a non factor as a second tall. He looks in great shape which showed with his 4 tackles which were all HTB and shots on goal.

- Class. He's a great kick both on goal and around the field which is a positive when it comes to SC numbers.



Cons to Tex:

- Reliant on opportunity from the midfield. He's spent the past couple of years starved of opportunity and when it comes in, it's a bomb on top of his head or something that goes about 5ft over his head. Walker is a terrible pack mark, great lead forward but Adelaide's midfield has typically struggled to kick it within a 10m radius of our forwards in the last, let alone to their advantage. Going on this, the delivery inside forward 50 was pretty poor against Sydney. Walker may have kicked 6.3 but 4 of those goals came from his tackling and HTB calls which was massive for his score. Great to see however I'm not banking on Walker's defensive tackling earning him many shots on goal either.

- Key forward. They're super hot and cold, two of his hot games come in scores that will only account for 1 and 2 prices rises respectively. Key forward in a pretty crap team (not going to call us anything other than that for a few more games yet).

- He's not a premium. You're spending a trade to make some cash and given he's got about 180k on your base priced rookie, you're really requiring him to put up some alright scores in the process to make giving up the 180k short term worth it.

- Age/history. Turns 31 and has only played a full season once in 2019. you're going back to 2012 when he actually put up premium numbers but it's a different Walker and a different Adelaide now. 2017 he put up an 86 average but that only included 5 scores over 100.Since 2017 he's only gone over 100+ once in each season.
 
Joined
18 Sep 2012
Messages
225
Likes
845
AFL Club
Adelaide
Just on Gaff, at the game today I watched him a fair bit because I've got him in RDT, but I noticed that the new rules have pretty-much bypassed the need to have a number of loose outlet players from 40-70m out.

The entire defence gets pushed back at the kick-in so your back pockets and KPDs are at that area where the second kick used to go, which was generally to a wingman playing on the defensive half of the ground. That used to be Gaff's area where he won a lot of the footy, but now he's not needed nearly as much.

Basically he hasn't become obsolete, because teams are still using that kick, it's just far rarer that they do use it because the area is generally packed with players so there's very little space. He might need to reinvent himself, but at this stage he's an easy trade-out for me from a DT perspective.
Great post. My last minute decision to grab him in DT has certainly backfired. Thought his tank and running along the wings all game would help score quite well however he hasn't and you might be spot on with what you've seen. Probably straight to Jordon myself with some cash to use soon.
 
Joined
13 Mar 2021
Messages
13
Likes
35
AFL Club
St Kilda
I want to however I'm really hesitant to trade in my favourite player as I don't want to get extra ****ty when our forward line delivery sucks and he can't get into the game.

Pros to Tex:

- Fixture.

GC, North, Freo, Hawthorn, GWS are our next 5 games. We should be relatively competitive in all of those which should at least give our forward line a little bit of supply, whether it's good is the big question.

GC I imagine he'll likely get Collins who is pretty decent, held Kennedy to 2.2 and nothing to gain by looking at his match up v North.

North are without Tarrant which has to help, no idea who is playing in his stead as I only really plan to watch North once this year (unless we play them twice).

Freo have been pretty undersized down back for a while now. McDonald was made to look like a star in round 1 against Hamling who went out, not sure who is next in line after him.

Hawks will have the Frost match I imagine. His speed might be alright against Tex on the lead however Riewoldt managed to kick 4 on him on the weekend. Held Wright to a goal but Wright is pretty unproven.

GWS should be a Davis matchup which will probably be pretty tough but with how GWS are playing, maybe we're a chance to be competitive against them.

- Form. With him rolling the way he is, we're looking to kick it to him a lot and Frampton is a bit of a non factor as a second tall. He looks in great shape which showed with his 4 tackles which were all HTB and shots on goal.

- Class. He's a great kick both on goal and around the field which is a positive when it comes to SC numbers.



Cons to Tex:

- Reliant on opportunity from the midfield. He's spent the past couple of years starved of opportunity and when it comes in, it's a bomb on top of his head or something that goes about 5ft over his head. Walker is a terrible pack mark, great lead forward but Adelaide's midfield has typically struggled to kick it within a 10m radius of our forwards in the last, let alone to their advantage. Going on this, the delivery inside forward 50 was pretty poor against Sydney. Walker may have kicked 6.3 but 4 of those goals came from his tackling and HTB calls which was massive for his score. Great to see however I'm not banking on Walker's defensive tackling earning him many shots on goal either.

- Key forward. They're super hot and cold, two of his hot games come in scores that will only account for 1 and 2 prices rises respectively. Key forward in a pretty crap team (not going to call us anything other than that for a few more games yet).

- He's not a premium. You're spending a trade to make some cash and given he's got about 180k on your base priced rookie, you're really requiring him to put up some alright scores in the process to make giving up the 180k short term worth it.

- Age/history. Turns 31 and has only played a full season once in 2019. you're going back to 2012 when he actually put up premium numbers but it's a different Walker and a different Adelaide now. 2017 he put up an 86 average but that only included 5 scores over 100.Since 2017 he's only gone over 100+ once in each season.
Jeeeepers those next 5 games he could go off. About his cash generation, he will go up to around 380k or so with a ton this week!! That’s huge and there’s not many players who will be rising that much at the start of the year.
 
Joined
17 Feb 2013
Messages
1,474
Likes
3,407
AFL Club
Collingwood
Issues:
Neale: Just ugh....
Sharp: Would like to keep around for DPP and FD in the coming weeks
McNeil: Can only keep one of him and Scott I think
Hunter: He's not much chop after all. Still.... from that 102k base, he only needs one good game
Fullarton: Bit of a spaz but will come in useful when I grab Marshall. Good chance to get more 1st ruck duties with the injury to the Big O
Scott: See McNeil
Fyfe: I can hold on.

Wants:
Jordon: Yeah he looks good
Warner: "The Chad" plays Richmond this week. I got a nasty feeling it's a trap. But his numbers are good and you have to pick him.

76k ITB

I've already traded Danger to Dunkley so am not too keen on trading Neale but damn he looked bad. Can't say he looks like getting good preparation for next weekend's match, the way things aer going right now either. I want those two rookies and think the best bet would be to trade him down to Jordon and pocket the cash. I started with 13 keepers, so I have the room in the upgrade plan. Thing is, he is about to play my beloved Pies and the only way I can see us keeping him quiet is if I not only keep him, but also put the (c) on him.

Gonna be a real test of Brisbane's character this week. I'm also keen to see if the umpiring department decides to take pity on them after the weekend's effort and even things up a bit for them. Might have to raid the missus's Xanax or something.

Anyway... right now it's Neale, McNeil > Jordon, The Chad. Leaves me with 632k in the bank. Drops my keepers from 13 to 12, which is in no way ideal but with Neale projected to lose as much as 75k and Jordon projected to gain as much, I have the 150k needed to justify the downgrade within 1 round.

Next step: Will be getting at least 1 price rise out of my remaining rooks. There are a bunch of 650k players in Lloyd (would complete my backs), Oliver and Steele that I am interested in bringing in. Either option would leave maybe 100k ITB
 
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
Berry was ok but not sure there's enough meat on the bone to use a trade, doesn't win much footy, role becomes a concern once Crouch returns also.
Agree, he throws everything at the first half then fades, seems like a 50-60 type guy and with him running out of gas after one half it's really hard to see a big spike on his cards.

Don't think he hurts non owners tbh.
 
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
Holding Neale, what will be will be.
Jones to Jordon locked.
Cripps/Phillips to either Tex for money making or Dunkley for a top 2 fwd keeper, either way I will be getting Dunkley this week or next.
Dunkley playing North this week which means he could go off and score massive.
Tex's draw is extremely enticing but needs to make 200k minimum to be even close to be worth the 2 trades, I wouldn't consider the Tex move mid year but that money at the start is tempting.
 
Joined
15 Oct 2018
Messages
3,912
Likes
12,177
AFL Club
Essendon
You can say I'm giving up on Taranto and Cripps early but going those two to Titch and Tex and pocketing an extra 70k feels like a weight off my shoulders. GWS look god awful and Taranto looked terrible after 1/4 time today and I'm simply not confident that he can be a 100+ player, they are basically a side with midfield depth and very little else at this juncture. Having JKelly and Taranto in my side together feels very iff and i want to escape it.

Cripps just looks like a shadow of himself.

Not missing any of the important rookies with this move bar Impey, but I'm still carrying a few who seem fairly ordinary (Sharp, Koschitzke, Scott and Fullarton). Hopefully Fullarton can prove a useful loophole player soon.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,151
AFL Club
Geelong
Holding Neale, what will be will be.
Jones to Jordon locked.
Cripps/Phillips to either Tex for money making or Dunkley for a top 2 fwd keeper, either way I will be getting Dunkley this week or next.
Dunkley playing North this week which means he could go off and score massive.
Tex's draw is extremely enticing but needs to make 200k minimum to be even close to be worth the 2 trades, I wouldn't consider the Tex move mid year but that money at the start is tempting.
This is my problem with the Tex trade in, he wont be consistent enough and/or durable enough to be a keeper so you're going to use 2 trades there eventually, not sure he makes enough money to justify it.
 
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
This is my problem with the Tex trade in, he wont be consistent enough and/or durable enough to be a keeper so you're going to use 2 trades there eventually, not sure he makes enough money to justify it.
It's a tough one isn't it.
That Adelaide draw is salivating though, I can see him hitting 450-475k no problem but If he throws in a patterned Tex 40 game between R3-R7 it will stagnate his earnings reaching that 500-550k mark.

I am leaning towards just getting Dunkley in before the North game.

I think if your team is going great guns and you haven't used more than 2 trades by the end of this second round, Tex is probably worth it.
If your already 3-4 trades down from fixing other issues I think he is a pass.
 
Last edited:
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,151
AFL Club
Geelong
It's a tough one isn't it.
That Adelaide draw is salivating though, I can see him hitting 450-475k no problem but If he throws in a patterned Tex 40 game between R3-R7 it will stagnate his earnings reaching that 500-550k mark.

I am learning to just getting Dunkley in before the North game.

I think if your team is going great guns and you haven't used more than 2 trades by the end of this second round, Tex is probably worth it.
If your already 3-4 trades down from fixing other issues I think he is a pass.
My main issue is I dont really have the money to get to Walker, would have to do something like Dow-Berry Daniher-Walker and really not sure that's worth it, only used one trade as I haven't had the carnage of other coaches so definitely tempting.
 
Last edited:
Joined
3 May 2017
Messages
2,684
Likes
8,886
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I'm thinking option 2, 1, then 3rd, with 4th being bring in both Impey and Tex. Reason against Dusty is his inconsistent scoring over the last couple of years. I'm wondering given the large scale sell of Danger that I shouldn't just non-selection train and hope his poor scoring rears it's ugly head again... Welcome your thinking behind the Dusty combo.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,151
AFL Club
Geelong
I'm thinking option 2, 1, then 3rd, with 4th being bring in both Impey and Tex. Reason against Dusty is his inconsistent scoring over the last couple of years. I'm wondering given the large scale sell of Danger that I shouldn't just non-selection train and hope his poor scoring rears it's ugly head again... Welcome your thinking behind the Dusty combo.
Impey feels like a must to me if you didn't start him, no idea how he scored so **** last week, the role is there and 212k is a bargain.

Impey and Jordon the two must haves of the week for non owners, luckily have both.
 
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
I'm thinking option 2, 1, then 3rd, with 4th being bring in both Impey and Tex. Reason against Dusty is his inconsistent scoring over the last couple of years. I'm wondering given the large scale sell of Danger that I shouldn't just non-selection train and hope his poor scoring rears it's ugly head again... Welcome your thinking behind the Dusty combo.
Dusty looks good this season. Is 100k cheaper than Oliver and 50k cheaper than Mitchell, that's a significant saving if he can somewhat match their scoring, as you say though, Dusty has been known to drop cash on the back of games where he is seemingly ''taking it easy'' for a few rounds.
I also think it will be easier to pounce of a fallen mid premo in R7-onwards than it will be to identify and pounce on a fallen fwd premo.
It's a gut call really, if you feel dusty is in for a better year go him if not hold for the anticipated drop.
 
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
Impey feels like a must to me if you didn't start him, no idea how he scored so **** last week, the role is there and 212k is a bargain.

Impey and Jordon the two must haves of the week for non owners, luckily have both.
What role did he play? FanFooty has him listed as starting forward :unsure:
 
Top