Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
This depends on what your plans are for DPP.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
This depends on what your plans are for DPP.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,311
- Likes
- 31,152
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
This depends on what your plans are for DPP.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
If you have Flynn at R3 and Fullarton at F8, then when Flynn is ready to be traded you can conceivably trade him into a forward (via Fullarton DPP), or maybe even a midfielder or defender if your DPPs are set up correctly. Trade Flynn into Lloyd, maybe?
If you chop Fullarton from F8 now, then when you chop Flynn you'll only be able to trade down into a rookie. It will cost you an extra trade to use the cash from Flynn if you don't have Fullarton (or another F/R) as a forward.
So based on this, I'd do the trade that doesn't involve Fullarton.
- Joined
- 1 Nov 2019
- Messages
- 435
- Likes
- 2,565
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Prefer Bergman but it's a coinflip. Waterman JS right now is stronger but reckon it's much of a muchness, he's not contributing much outside goals so if they go away so could the spot (and SC scoring). Bergman seems to be basically the 23rd guy which with 2 guys out for 5+ weeks means he should be good if he performs but in a strong team with minor premiership aspirations he's in an earn it or lose it position.
Like Bergman's likely roles, be it wing or HB, more than Waterman's.
Petracca playing forward too much earlier in the season and with Fritsch out that doesn't help the cause, he's a guy in my sights once the KP forwards are back and he can go back to a midfield role, to be fair he played basically pure midfield last week but that was with Fritsch really holding it down up forward.
Merrett getting some really harsh scoring from CD, taking guys who have black tickets is always risky because they have to brute force their way out of it and there haven't been any midfielders putting up the kind of raw DT numbers needed to do that on any kind of consistent basis this year.
Honestly not sure I'd be targeting either of them right now, if in doubt, cheaper?
Like Bergman's likely roles, be it wing or HB, more than Waterman's.
Petracca playing forward too much earlier in the season and with Fritsch out that doesn't help the cause, he's a guy in my sights once the KP forwards are back and he can go back to a midfield role, to be fair he played basically pure midfield last week but that was with Fritsch really holding it down up forward.
Merrett getting some really harsh scoring from CD, taking guys who have black tickets is always risky because they have to brute force their way out of it and there haven't been any midfielders putting up the kind of raw DT numbers needed to do that on any kind of consistent basis this year.
Honestly not sure I'd be targeting either of them right now, if in doubt, cheaper?
Thank you both, great insights.
The ideal target would have been Oliver, however not enough dineros - and besides, he probably drops $20k this week.
It's a situation where I have the trade and cash this round to execute, with the intention of getting an extra round of premium scoring in. Not that enamoured with Merrett - previous season best of 115 and doesn't have the SC golden ticket. Also playing for a questionable team.
Petracca is an interesting one - sure he was playing forward a lot R1-3, however he still accumulated ~28 disposals each game. Butchered it plenty though. I am slightly concerned that he runs into Richmond in R6 and they put the handbrake on him for a 70-80, especially if he is stuck forward to replace Fritsch and the volume and quality of ball into F50 decreases.
The ideal target would have been Oliver, however not enough dineros - and besides, he probably drops $20k this week.
It's a situation where I have the trade and cash this round to execute, with the intention of getting an extra round of premium scoring in. Not that enamoured with Merrett - previous season best of 115 and doesn't have the SC golden ticket. Also playing for a questionable team.
Petracca is an interesting one - sure he was playing forward a lot R1-3, however he still accumulated ~28 disposals each game. Butchered it plenty though. I am slightly concerned that he runs into Richmond in R6 and they put the handbrake on him for a 70-80, especially if he is stuck forward to replace Fritsch and the volume and quality of ball into F50 decreases.
