Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
Is this for D6 or D5?
If it's D5 I'm taking Bowes, a third of the season is a pretty good sample size on two guys whose roles aren't changing and that 80k is valuable given they're scoring the same.
D6 I think I'd pay the premium for the certainty though and Lloyd's incredible durability record. Throw in that Lloyd is a Dawson injury from going back to last year while Bowes is kind of maxed out.
If it's D5 I'm taking Bowes, a third of the season is a pretty good sample size on two guys whose roles aren't changing and that 80k is valuable given they're scoring the same.
D6 I think I'd pay the premium for the certainty though and Lloyd's incredible durability record. Throw in that Lloyd is a Dawson injury from going back to last year while Bowes is kind of maxed out.
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,192
- Likes
- 2,132
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
+1
Gotta go with Lloyd imo, mainly for the reason that he is as durable a player as there is. Low physicality game, safe as houses.
Mills has been ok as well, but you know Lloyd is as good for 22 and 110+ as almost anyone in the league.
The durability aspect is even more important in defence given the dearth of playing coverage on the bench.
Gotta go with Lloyd imo, mainly for the reason that he is as durable a player as there is. Low physicality game, safe as houses.
Mills has been ok as well, but you know Lloyd is as good for 22 and 110+ as almost anyone in the league.
The durability aspect is even more important in defence given the dearth of playing coverage on the bench.
I'm still on neither. Titch was great without O'Meara but will he hold that role that he hasn't been playing all year, especially given they got spanked with him in it (it's his best role though!).
Kelly still hasn't shown much, to be fair his role was better this week, love to know his CBA but it seemed to actually be a few at least.
Still prefer Gaff or generating the cash for Steele over those two personally.
They could both go huge obviously but durability is definitely an issue and Mitchell's role has not been great this year so I do worry it's just an O'Meara related spike. Eagles also allow a lot of cheap touches.
Mills for D5, Lloyd if it's D6.
Stand by what I've been saying since the second it was said that Mills would play midfield though that he can average 115+ in that role, he's so clearly our best midfielder, the only person who doesn't seem to know it at this point is Horse and even then I think he just doesn't value the midfield, at all.
But Lloyd is the safe pick, you need someone to play 14 games, average 105+ from here, he's just about the safest pick in any position.
Yep, that durability is big, Mills has been pretty good, but has picked up a few injuries and inside midfielders do get banged a lot more than seagulls feasting on chips.
Kelly still hasn't shown much, to be fair his role was better this week, love to know his CBA but it seemed to actually be a few at least.
Still prefer Gaff or generating the cash for Steele over those two personally.
They could both go huge obviously but durability is definitely an issue and Mitchell's role has not been great this year so I do worry it's just an O'Meara related spike. Eagles also allow a lot of cheap touches.
Mills for D5, Lloyd if it's D6.
Stand by what I've been saying since the second it was said that Mills would play midfield though that he can average 115+ in that role, he's so clearly our best midfielder, the only person who doesn't seem to know it at this point is Horse and even then I think he just doesn't value the midfield, at all.
But Lloyd is the safe pick, you need someone to play 14 games, average 105+ from here, he's just about the safest pick in any position.
Yep, that durability is big, Mills has been pretty good, but has picked up a few injuries and inside midfielders do get banged a lot more than seagulls feasting on chips.
- Joined
- 14 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 1,192
- Likes
- 2,132
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
REALLY struggling to find good upgrades, id appreciates it loads if someone would be able to give any input plsss
Ok bit of an odd XvY(vZ) for my H2H
Option 1: Final Defense upgrade
Bowes v Weitering v Docherty v Lloyd
-- Rookie=Dawkins ---
Option 2: Midfield Upgrade
Sloane v Mitchell v Ellis
---- Rookie=Poulter/Owies/H Edwards ----
Option 3: Forward Line upgrade
Impey v Marshell(rd 14 bye) v Hall v Sidebottom
---- Rookie= Dawkins ----
Any and all advise is welcome and much needed
Ok bit of an odd XvY(vZ) for my H2H
Option 1: Final Defense upgrade
Bowes v Weitering v Docherty v Lloyd
-- Rookie=Dawkins ---
Option 2: Midfield Upgrade
Sloane v Mitchell v Ellis
---- Rookie=Poulter/Owies/H Edwards ----
Option 3: Forward Line upgrade
Impey v Marshell(rd 14 bye) v Hall v Sidebottom
---- Rookie= Dawkins ----
Any and all advise is welcome and much needed
