Position 2022: Defender Discussion

Joined
3 Feb 2021
Messages
2,410
Likes
13,067
AFL Club
Essendon
I probably think differently to most and you could argue it costs me from being a genuine contender but I much rather select the guys I want to pick not pick with 3 rounds of the season in mind, one bad round really isnt the end of the world.
I'll admit I tend to over-analyse the bye rounds but I generally see it as an opportunity to improve my rank and in most cases I've been successful. But it is a fine line and I agree you can sometimes end up compromising your team in the long run.

Best 18 certainly helps and, like any other round, the key is to avoid donuts. I also tend to focus on the total score for all three rounds rather than the highs and lows. At the end of the day, it's a sum of 57 scores (54 + 3Cs).

In the past, the assumption with your "keepers" is you've got them for 2 out of 3 rounds but I think the extra trades will provide more opportunities / temptation for premo sideways moves this year. Whether that's a help or a hindrance remains to be seen.

Coming back to the original comment, the boosters may also prove useful in the first two rounds - making adjustments to grab the right rookies / tinker with structure but it's a long way to the finish from round 2 so the risk is greater.
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
I probably think differently to most and you could argue it costs me from being a genuine contender but I much rather select the guys I want to pick not pick with 3 rounds of the season in mind, one bad round really isnt the end of the world.
But 3 good rounds will set you apart from the pack who think 1 bad round doesn't matter, I try to treat them together and aim for 6k pts over the byes.
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
I'll admit I tend to over-analyse the bye rounds but I generally see it as an opportunity to improve my rank and in most cases I've been successful. But it is a fine line and I agree you can sometimes end up compromising your team in the long run.

Best 18 certainly helps and, like any other round, the key is to avoid donuts. I also tend to focus on the total score for all three rounds rather than the highs and lows. At the end of the day, it's a sum of 57 scores (54 + 3Cs).

In the past, the assumption with your "keepers" is you've got them for 2 out of 3 rounds but I think the extra trades will provide more opportunities / temptation for premo sideways moves this year. Whether that's a help or a hindrance remains to be seen.

Coming back to the original comment, the boosters may also prove useful in the first two rounds - making adjustments to grab the right rookies / tinker with structure but it's a long way to the finish from round 2 so the risk is greater.
My thoughts are in relation to the chasing of rookies on the bubble, too many times I've had to make the choice between 2 or 3 and inevitably miss out on one. Come upgrade season, providing the funds and the 2nd tranche of rookies are there, then there's the possibility of getting 2 extra upgrades in over 4 rounds. Instead of going 1 up, 1 down per round over say 4 rounds with 8 trades it's conceivable to use 12 trades over those 4 rounds and get 6 upgrades done.
 
Joined
4 Mar 2022
Messages
2
Likes
11
AFL Club
Richmond
Can somebody please explain the hype around Coleman this year? Looking at his past few seasons he doesn't seem to be a big SC scorer and yet I see him in a bunch of teams. I have the cash to trade him in for Sinn but would like to know why he is so popular?
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,906
AFL Club
West Coast
Can somebody please explain the hype around Coleman this year? Looking at his past few seasons he doesn't seem to be a big SC scorer and yet I see him in a bunch of teams. I have the cash to trade him in for Sinn but would like to know why he is so popular?
Without being rude, this question has been answered so many times already…

Top right of the site has a search option, click on that & type in Coleman for your answer (y)
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
Can someone tell me if Dan Rioli has had an uninterrupted pre season? I think he missed a practice match recently.
Haven't heard anything, might have been Covid related, loads managed, or an opportunity to look at Hugo (The Boss) and give him a bit of exposure. I reckon HRS is the depth/backup for Rioli.
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
Rioli's SC scores seemed to pick up a bit late last year, was he playing half back then?
He was moved into defence in rnd 18 and if you discount a 54 where he had 7 clangers ( a bit better ball user than that) then he averaged 91. He's been training with the backs all preseason and has been talked up by Tim Livingstone just recently.
 
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
He was moved into defence in rnd 18 and if you discount a 54 where he had 7 clangers ( a bit better ball user than that) then he averaged 91. He's been training with the backs all preseason and has been talked up by Tim Livingstone just recently.
Thanks for the info. Much appreciated.
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,769
Likes
26,255
AFL Club
Sydney
I'll admit I tend to over-analyse the bye rounds but I generally see it as an opportunity to improve my rank and in most cases I've been successful. But it is a fine line and I agree you can sometimes end up compromising your team in the long run.

Best 18 certainly helps and, like any other round, the key is to avoid donuts. I also tend to focus on the total score for all three rounds rather than the highs and lows. At the end of the day, it's a sum of 57 scores (54 + 3Cs).

In the past, the assumption with your "keepers" is you've got them for 2 out of 3 rounds but I think the extra trades will provide more opportunities / temptation for premo sideways moves this year. Whether that's a help or a hindrance remains to be seen.

Coming back to the original comment, the boosters may also prove useful in the first two rounds - making adjustments to grab the right rookies / tinker with structure but it's a long way to the finish from round 2 so the risk is greater.
Find the byes very difficult to plan, outside avoiding picking 3 premiums from the same team in the same position then mostly they're about planning in rounds 8-11 and through the byes.

You just can't plan for the x, y and z players that become must haves, be they rookies or premiums, during the season at the start. They become a factor as you approach and are picking from likely 50/50 decisions with most information known.

Like right now, I'm picking the better player, imo, and then will worry about the byes. Preseason for me it's a tiebreaker only.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,807
AFL Club
Collingwood
Not sure if this will work or not (but like how the rest of my team looks) :-

Lloyd , Whitfield , Sicily , Hinge , Gibcus , McCartin / Sinn , De Koning or Kelly
 
Joined
7 Apr 2012
Messages
3,096
Likes
5,921
AFL Club
Adelaide
With Coleman out think I’ll change my structure from 3-1-2 to 4-0-2. Defence looks really shaky with Hinge at D4 and very limited alternatives to Coleman in a similar price bracket.
Yeah Coleman is really the only defender i really wanted to pick who is between 200-500k and he looked great.

I was pretty set on Lloyd, Short, Whitfield, Coleman and 4 rookies and i am certainly looking at a change of plans now be another premo or Hewett. I find Hewett a bit meh but i can get a nice side with 11 premos plus him, berry, coniglio so it isn't the end of the world.

Left field thought - if Gibcus with the E scoring well on a Thursday night could have me tempted to start Kiddy anyway if the hammy is on the low grade end of things
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
Yeah Coleman is really the only defender i really wanted to pick who is between 200-500k and he looked great.

I was pretty set on Lloyd, Short, Whitfield, Coleman and 4 rookies and i am certainly looking at a change of plans now be another premo or Hewett. I find Hewett a bit meh but i can get a nice side with 11 premos plus him, berry, coniglio so it isn't the end of the world.

Left field thought - if Gibcus with the E scoring well on a Thursday night could have me tempted to start Kiddy anyway if the hammy is on the low grade end of things
If Coleman misses the 1st 2 games then he'll be on the bubble come rnd 5, good opportunity to assess him over a couple of games.
 
Top