Strategy 2022: Round 3 Trades
- Thread starter Tamuhawk
- Start date
- Joined
- 6 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 4,890
- Likes
- 11,148
- AFL Club
- West Coast
One commentator mentioned in game one they thought he walked of the ground funny and doing a lot of lift leg up and outwards (groin stretching). Someone mentioned game 2 he was running in 2nd gear only. Is it a slight strain or more or nothing. Remember sitting on Kelly for ages until they told us OP. Neale last year, they told us nothing.
Cracking backline except for donut. Bowey does make quick money yet needs some 80-90's to make the 150k. As aggressive as I am, I would trade McGov to Heeney knowing he is probably 100k underpriced and potn keeper. McGov could still make us money, has a good role, although, coach did make a comment after the game which questioned (in my mind) whether McGov may play 2s for a couple of weeks to learn role.
Caldwell should be looked at. For Berry, just not sure. Berry did play a cooler role which hurt his scoring and has a range of concerns including injury issues, as does Caldwell have history. Think these trades make more sense when you know the outgoing target is going to lose money.
Took a lot of intercept marks, at 176cm I can assure you they were uncontested. Elite user of the ball, yet needs to get the ball. Highly dependent on role, needs HB not back pocket. If named at HB flank (with Hibberd in side) then 80-90 is quite possible going forward and expect he is traded in by many.
Cracking backline except for donut. Bowey does make quick money yet needs some 80-90's to make the 150k. As aggressive as I am, I would trade McGov to Heeney knowing he is probably 100k underpriced and potn keeper. McGov could still make us money, has a good role, although, coach did make a comment after the game which questioned (in my mind) whether McGov may play 2s for a couple of weeks to learn role.
Caldwell should be looked at. For Berry, just not sure. Berry did play a cooler role which hurt his scoring and has a range of concerns including injury issues, as does Caldwell have history. Think these trades make more sense when you know the outgoing target is going to lose money.
Took a lot of intercept marks, at 176cm I can assure you they were uncontested. Elite user of the ball, yet needs to get the ball. Highly dependent on role, needs HB not back pocket. If named at HB flank (with Hibberd in side) then 80-90 is quite possible going forward and expect he is traded in by many.
Given the lack of cheap cash cows I think the chase for cash and value is more important this year. We now have more information. I would rather trade a Whitfield than a Berry or McGovern. Not that Whitfield can't turn it around but he probably gets more people into some of those players that look heavily underpriced. I wouldn't be trading a keeper to chase another fully priced keeper who is off to a hot start. That's just chasing last weeks points.
The more I think about things, the more I'm lost... here's where I'm at.
Lloyd, Short, Whitfield, Hewett, Hinge, McCartin (Gibcus, SDK)
Steele, Miller, Neale, Cripps, Rowell, J.Berry, JHF, ND (D.Stephens, Ward, Owens)
Grawndy (Hayes)
Dunkley, Butters, Cogs, Brodie, Xerri, Rachele (Durdin, Martin)
Tempted to trade Gawn to English but that's about where the thoughts stop... no rookies scream out at me. Whitfield looks like he's not 100% and want to get rid of him, but a lot of the other defenders concern me.
Lloyd, Short, Whitfield, Hewett, Hinge, McCartin (Gibcus, SDK)
Steele, Miller, Neale, Cripps, Rowell, J.Berry, JHF, ND (D.Stephens, Ward, Owens)
Grawndy (Hayes)
Dunkley, Butters, Cogs, Brodie, Xerri, Rachele (Durdin, Martin)
Tempted to trade Gawn to English but that's about where the thoughts stop... no rookies scream out at me. Whitfield looks like he's not 100% and want to get rid of him, but a lot of the other defenders concern me.
Yep. Xerri looks like he had a very fortunate spike game. Playing East Perth without NicNat. I would think the rnd 1 score is closer to the norm. If you already have him you'd be happy but I don't see the need to trade him in. Even though we're lacking in cheap cash cows it looks like there is still plenty of cash to be made in other ways.
I'm not necessarily against trading Berry but it would have to be for a must have cheap cash cow or value keeper. Give him another week and reasses for maybe an NMartin next week. I would rather use a cold higher priced premium to get JHF and it might let you get in an undervalue keeper like Cripps, Hewett or Heeney if you didn't have them.
Edit: Supposed to quote @Vicwood. Don't know what happened.
Edit: Supposed to quote @Vicwood. Don't know what happened.
- Joined
- 24 Feb 2015
- Messages
- 6,697
- Likes
- 30,160
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Re: Xerri - he looked very good in that role sharing ruck time with Goldy, I wouldn't take out the value of CCJ missing from that team but yes they were playing a somewhat spirited 2nd string Weagles. Xerri can make some coin I think.
I'm probably going to hold Berry for one more week also, I'd like to see him against NM and he's not going to lose money - for me I'll bring in both Stephens and Rachele and move Whitfield to Hall I think and re-assess another week.
I'm probably going to hold Berry for one more week also, I'd like to see him against NM and he's not going to lose money - for me I'll bring in both Stephens and Rachele and move Whitfield to Hall I think and re-assess another week.
Tossing up between two trading strategies.. interested to hear everybody's thoughts:
Option 1)
Whitfield out --> Hewett in
Berry out --> Rowell in
McGovern --> Xerri in
or
Option 2)
Whitfield out --> Bowey in
McGovern out --> Heeney in
Ideally would love to go strategy 1 but replace Xerri with Heeney, however am about $2K short.
Option 1)
Whitfield out --> Hewett in
Berry out --> Rowell in
McGovern --> Xerri in
or
Option 2)
Whitfield out --> Bowey in
McGovern out --> Heeney in
Ideally would love to go strategy 1 but replace Xerri with Heeney, however am about $2K short.
