Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[BomberSam]

Oliver Wines vs. Lachie Neale

Zac Williams vs. Dan Houston

Kyle Langford vs. Toby Greene


Thanks in advance for any thoughts.

Neale

Houston

KLangers

All of them very close though, could go either way.

Dale v Hawkins, playing for leagues. Identical in price and average

Dale. Less variation in his score. He's not as likely to win you a match up with a huge score, but he's far less likely to lose you a match up with a spud score.

Lyons v Parish v Neale for final mid

Parish, your 2021 Brownlow medalist.

 

[jaca]

Lyons v Parish v Neale for final mid

Neale for me.

 

[Connoisseur]

Oliver Wines vs. Lachie Neale

Zac Williams vs. Dan Houston

Kyle Langford vs. Toby Greene


Thanks in advance for any thoughts.

L Neale very comfortably. Do no rate Wines as an option at his current price.
Houston over Williams due to the cheaper price and higher average. Better suited to the defensive role rather than in the midfield and I am considering him myself as a D7 this round.
Greene over Langford. More proven, nice draw and has been very inaccurate on occasions this season but has still delivered very respectable scores.

 

[Weedys Crop]

Who has better JS Edwards v Bramble

 

[dlanod]

Who has better JS Edwards v Bramble

Edwards because he's played two games and hasn't been dropped yet.

Bramble hasn't played any, could do absolutely nothing or completely smash it, but in the complete absence of any AFL form you'd have to pick the guy that's held his spot once already.

 

[WindyHillWizard]

L Neale very comfortably. Do no rate Wines as an option at his current price.
Houston over Williams due to the cheaper price and higher average. Better suited to the defensive role rather than in the midfield and I am considering him myself as a D7 this round.
Greene over Langford. More proven, nice draw and has been very inaccurate on occasions this season but has still delivered very respectable scores.

This advise from last Friday has aged very well over the weekend! 👍

 

[wogitalia]

Who has better JS Edwards v Bramble

Edwards has played two very good games but that will mean nothing if he has two bad ones in a team that still believes it can win a flag.

That's still better than a guy with no runs on the board at all.

The value of Bramble's score this week, hopefully the only time either plays, and that 15k is definitely a factor though to be considered.

 

[warewolves]

Retrospective
Coming into Round 10 there were heaps of impassioned posts and members weighing in on the merits of trading in Dusty Martin vs Aaron Hall.
There have now been 4 rounds of actuals since then and the Hall camp are comfortably winning the argument on both counts - points & $$$.
This little table shows the round 11-14 comparisons.

The blue labelled column adjusts Dusty's points up by a factor of about 7% - given that his points were purchased for a lower price.
I went with Dusty and (aside from the Hall opportunity) it seems like it was a really good trade.
Perhaps the best course was to get both of them!

 

[Blue Bloods]

Highmore to either Edwards or Bramble.

Technically Highmore will make some more cash in coming weeks (Poulter too, and Neale dropping) but I still have Robertson and Flynn fully priced to target Grundy back in, along with Bianco and CCJ looking solid so the value of having an extra premium this week instead of a donut (100 points) outweighs the cash ($100k).

Definitely leaning towards Neale FWIW.

Hope you got Neale.

 

[Crabby Skills]

Retrospective
Coming into Round 10 there were heaps of impassioned posts and members weighing in on the merits of trading in Dusty Martin vs Aaron Hall.
There have now been 4 rounds of actuals since then and the Hall camp are comfortably winning the argument on both counts - points & $$$.
This little table shows the round 11-14 comparisons.
View attachment 31530
The blue labelled column adjusts Dusty's points up by a factor of about 7% - given that his points were purchased for a lower price.
I went with Dusty and (aside from the Hall opportunity) it seems like it was a really good trade.
Perhaps the best course was to get both of them!

What if you got Hall in rd 8 at 415k ...


(the second trade however can be ignored pls and thanks )

 

[dlanod]

Hope you got Neale.

Yep, doubly happy with his lack of a price drop.

 

[NT.Thunder]

If you could take one of Neale or Danger for the remainder of this season who would it be for you?

 

[GrainFedBeef]

If you could take one of Neale or Danger for the remainder of this season who would it be for you?

Both coming off similar injuries. Neale as his role is secure. I expect Danger should get more CBA’s, although Jezza impacts this if injured.

Neale has shown more (2 scores) and younger.

 

[Blue Bloods]

If you could take one of Neale or Danger for the remainder of this season who would it be for you?

Neale for points, Danger for price.

Getting both if possible.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Walsh Vs Boak

Who scores more from now on?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Dangerfield vs Sidebottom

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Boak or Walsh?
Can't get the Bont

 

[NT.Thunder]

Boak or Walsh?
Can't get the Bont

There’s a long way from a Boak/Walsh to Bont 😂😂😂
Probably Walsh for me.

 

[Chumpion]

Walsh Vs Boak

Who scores more from now on?

Boak or Walsh?
Can't get the Bont

If going for overall I think Walsh outscores Boak in the run home (but it will be a close one!).

If going for leagues, keep in mind Walsh has GWS in the final round which kept him to 71 points a few rounds ago.

I probably have Walsh scoring 110-115 in the run home and Boak 105-110

 

[Chumpion]

Dangerfield vs Sidebottom

Personally I like Danger. He's had some good first half scores lately before fading a little in the second.. just needs to build that match fitness up but I think he's close to going large. Has a good next 5 games and could easily average 120 in that period.