Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[quite ironic]

Macrae & Dusty
V
Oliver & Neale


Laird & Whitfield
V
Simpson & Hurn

Macrae and Dusty

Laird and Whitfield (but this seems a fair bit more expensive than option 2?)

 

[Yasi]

Goldy and Greene (Moore D4)
Vs
Grundy and Collins (Moore F4)

 

[Juzzo]

Goldy and Greene (Moore D4)
Vs
Grundy and Collins (Moore F4)

2nd one.
ATM I've got Grundy, Greene (F3) and Moore (D4)

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Hore + McKay (both bench) + Fyfe + Treloar - 6 premo midfield

vs

Whitfield (M1) + Collins + BCrouch (M5) + LIbba (M6). - Whitfields/Collins push J Clarke/Duursma to the bench.

Going for league. - stronger mid/weaker defence vs improved defence and solid mid price performers.

 

[Juzzo]

Fyfe, Rookie
v
2 of Crouch/Rocky/Libba

 

[quite ironic]

Fyfe, Rookie
v
2 of Crouch/Rocky/Libba

Fyfe and rookie.

Both risky for different reasons but more cash generation in option 2 imo and less trades if things don’t work.

 

[Tommy79]

Dusty, Merrett or Matt Crouch?

 

[Leroy]

Dusty, Merrett or Matt Crouch?

The group think on here says Matt Crouch.
Dusty if you like him, Zerret as a trade in once he warms up.

 

[Ricky Bobby]

Mundy v T Kelly ? And what do they average ?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Dusty, Merrett or Matt Crouch?

Matt Crouch slightly ahead of Dusty with Merrett a long way behind.

Mundy v T Kelly ? And what do they average ?

T Kelly for mine. I think Kelly will average around 100 and Mundy will average around 95.

 

[spangleduck]

Dusty, Merrett or Matt Crouch?

Dusty>Zerrett>Crouch. I've got the first two at this stage.

 

[pizza safety]

His average last season was impacted by playing as a tagger for most rounds of the first half of the season. Post byes he was relieved of tagging duties and he averaged 111.8. Just needs to carry that form into this year for a 110 average. Not saying he will, but I think he’s a decent chance.

pretty sure he tagged more in the second half of the year but mostly just at stoppages. Dunstan was tagging poorly in the first half. He’s meant to tag less this year

 

[pizza safety]

Macrae and Dusty

Laird and Whitfield (but this seems a fair bit more expensive than option 2?)

Oliver and Neale

Laid and Whitfield

 

[Bomber18]

Mundy v T Kelly ? And what do they average ?

I'm unsure on both of these guys, but think they could both average 90-95. T Kelly possibly has an upside of 100, but it'd have to be at Menegola or Jelwood's expense? Kelly had big CBAs during the JLT but Jelwood's CBAs appeared to be right down. I can't pick Telly with confidence but if I had to choose against Mundy, I'd pick Telly as he has an upside of 100 (but I worry he's going to average closer to 90 if he can't get consistent mid time and / or is played out of position if he declares he's going home).

 

[Jim's Dim Sims]

Rocky and B Crouch vs Macrae and Rookie

 

[Ricky Bobby]

I'm unsure on both of these guys, but think they could both average 90-95. T Kelly possibly has an upside of 100, but it'd have to be at Menegola or Jelwood's expense? Kelly had big CBAs during the JLT but Jelwood's CBAs appeared to be right down. I can't pick Telly with confidence but if I had to choose against Mundy, I'd pick Telly as he has an upside of 100 (but I worry he's going to average closer to 90 if he can't get consistent mid time and / or is played out of position if he declares he's going home).

Thanks B18. Do you have an alternative preferred option in the $500 - $520 range?

 

[Bomber18]

Rocky and B Crouch vs Macrae and Rookie

Hmmm... I guess this applies to me as well considering I currently have both Rocky and B Crouch in my side. Seeing the XY, you'd have to say Macrae and Rookie (although who is that rookie? Hind? Are they on field?). But I have Rocky and B Crouch as it stands so I guess I'm not as confident on the mid rookie JS.

 

[Bomber18]

Thanks B18. Do you have an alternative preferred option in the $500 - $520 range?

Robbie Gray is in my side - although he's just $5k outside of that range....

 

[Juzzo]

Dusty>Zerrett>Crouch. I've got the first two at this stage.

Hey Spangle, how many midpricers are you rolling with this year?

 

[quite ironic]

Thanks B18. Do you have an alternative preferred option in the $500 - $520 range?

I like Dunkley personally