Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[freowho]

Looking at Hunter> Hickey as well as Phillips>Impey. 1300 short of getting both trades done this week. Hunter is R3 Have Grundy, Flynn
Fwds are Dunkley, Danger (mid bench), Phillips, Ziebell, Daniher, Campbell, Warner, - Rowe, Jones 28 trades and 107,600 ITB

Thought I could get 120 cash gen from Hickey and points gain per week as well as get closer to a Gawn trade. Phillips>Impey will get smaller points gain in short term but more cash and points by time trade is ready R14/15 at this stage.

You don't need Hickey if you have Grundy and Flynn.

 

[Billyboy171920]

Ideally it would be none of them. Three fit keepers, and while Danger will miss this game, he’s probably F1 or maybe F2 this year.

Do you have a need to trade one of them for another reason (eg to fund a major restructure)?

I need to trade them to get ridley

 

[Darkie]

I need to trade them to get ridley

Okay. In that case I don't think any of those trades is worthwhile.

If you were set on trading one of them, I'd go Daniel.

 

[wogitalia]

I need to trade them to get ridley

No you don't. You're thinking of trading 3 guys of whom 1 may well outaverage from here and two may very easily match.

That's just bad sideways trading. Work out how to get there without a sideways loss being made.

 

[Johnsy44]

Tex vs Impey and 100k

Leaning towards Tex as I can see him being a season keeper with the shape and form he is in, added with he is playing against training cones on sunday

 

[gutsroy]

If bringing in Chapman, whom to cull?

Sharp (DPP) vs. Koschitzke

 

[Inside50]

If bringing in Chapman, whom to cull?

Sharp (DPP) vs. Koschitzke

Sharp. Kosi might hold his spot.

 

[Inside50]

Tex vs Impey and 100k

Leaning towards Tex as I can see him being a season keeper with the shape and form he is in, added with he is playing against training cones on sunday

Have both but prefer Tex, think he’ll be top 8. However if he doesn’t get there he can still make you $150k which is enough.

 

[Johnsy44]

Who to trade, a Non-playing Sharp with DPP or a Kosi who may hold his spot but may not, and already has a 22 BE

For Chapman

 

[wogitalia]

Who to trade, a Non-playing Sharp with DPP or a Kosi who may hold his spot but may not, and already has a 22 BE

For Chapman

Always keep the guy who is a chance to make cash. Kosi against a wounded backline could well put up an 80 and be in play.

Believe Box Hill play tomorrow though so will probably have an answer on him at least.

 

[Vicwood]

Any news on Chapman being confirmed to play Sunday.?

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Any news on Chapman being confirmed to play Sunday.?

Haven't seen any comment all week, no reason to think he will not play. Young injured and I think they gain one defender back (Logue). Other defenders are noted at 2+ or 4+ weeks away.

 

[Vicwood]

Haven't seen any comment all week, no reason to think he will not play. Young injured and I think they gain one defender back (Logue). Other defenders are noted at 2+ or 4+ weeks away.

Yes. That’s my concern need him for at least 3 price increase.?

 

[Montyjnr]

Bowes vs Short

 

[Bontempele]

Neale probably gotta go. Titch, Merrett or Petracca?

 

[craig freer]

Sholl v C.J
Thanks in advance

 

[Pieman17]

Steele V Petracca V Oliver V Titch

Steele looks the best but arguably overpriced compared to the rest, although some of them still have somewhat high BEs and could drop some more.

 

[Pieman17]

Bowes vs Short

Short I think.

 

[Pieman17]

Sholl v C.J
Thanks in advance

Neither personally can’t see them being keepers or making another cash to justify the trade.

I’d probably go CJ out of the two though.

 

[Johnsy44]

Currently have 723k to spend after trading Mr 19. Team is as pictured below. Bowes and 219k vs Houston and 183k vs Macrae and 79k vs Steele and 70k vs Heppell and 405k. Open to any suggestions. Currently leaning towards Heppell as next week could go Jordan to Prem Mid?