Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y
- Thread starter Leroy
- Start date
Libba stays fit hell beat all of those blokes home for mine, good draw and is so contested post Dunkley leaving that he just scores points for fun, only one I really prefer as a premo mid from here is Trac but hes getting to the point that the ownership is way too high and may tire having carried such a massive load for basically 2 months straight.
- Joined
- 28 Sep 2020
- Messages
- 717
- Likes
- 3,322
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I’m a h2h focus guy. Sitting 2 wins inside the 4. Got 2 mids left to complete my side.
I’ve got Bont, Laird, Merrett, Neale, Walsh and JDG.
One comes in this week for Cincotta, have a lazy 396k itb so can afford anyone besides Trac.
The last mid will be one up one down Johnson and Mitchell.
Do I go the best option now (Libba it seems?) and hope I can afford Oliver in a couple weeks, or a cheaper option (eg serong) to give myself a better chance at Oliver?
Have 3 trades left after but want to save them for injuries in h2h finals.
I’ve got Bont, Laird, Merrett, Neale, Walsh and JDG.
One comes in this week for Cincotta, have a lazy 396k itb so can afford anyone besides Trac.
The last mid will be one up one down Johnson and Mitchell.
Do I go the best option now (Libba it seems?) and hope I can afford Oliver in a couple weeks, or a cheaper option (eg serong) to give myself a better chance at Oliver?
Have 3 trades left after but want to save them for injuries in h2h finals.
- Joined
- 22 Jun 2023
- Messages
- 409
- Likes
- 1,889
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Still weighing up the Petracca or Libba dilemma to complete my team.
Will end on 4 trades + a DEF/FWD loop for Seamus as cover regardless of who I pick.
History, age and numbers tell me that Petracca is the guy. Did 120 after the bye last year and interestingly, a lot of his big games this year came with less CBAs. He is a very damaging midfielder going forward and feels like the "all rounder" player.
But Libba is quietly scratching at the door. Clearly his best year so far, but he's only averaged one year above 110. I have to ask myself, do I think he continues to average 118? I'm not sure - but then I'm not sure if Petracca does either. Libba did 106 after the bye last year but looks to have turned a corner.
Lots of mouths to feed on the Dogs, but hasn't seemed to bother Libba so far. I assume Oliver will be back after this week, which should be able to lighten some of the load for Petracca going forward.
Both guys have a pretty much identical run home and both are very good.
Ownership in the top 1% favors Petracca and makes Libba more of a POD. Stats wise, there is not much to split them either.
Maybe I'm overthinking this one. I need a drink.
Will end on 4 trades + a DEF/FWD loop for Seamus as cover regardless of who I pick.
History, age and numbers tell me that Petracca is the guy. Did 120 after the bye last year and interestingly, a lot of his big games this year came with less CBAs. He is a very damaging midfielder going forward and feels like the "all rounder" player.
But Libba is quietly scratching at the door. Clearly his best year so far, but he's only averaged one year above 110. I have to ask myself, do I think he continues to average 118? I'm not sure - but then I'm not sure if Petracca does either. Libba did 106 after the bye last year but looks to have turned a corner.
Lots of mouths to feed on the Dogs, but hasn't seemed to bother Libba so far. I assume Oliver will be back after this week, which should be able to lighten some of the load for Petracca going forward.
Both guys have a pretty much identical run home and both are very good.
Ownership in the top 1% favors Petracca and makes Libba more of a POD. Stats wise, there is not much to split them either.
Maybe I'm overthinking this one. I need a drink.
